Sigma Percentile
JEE Advanced 2021
LEVELJEE Advanced

Animated Solution for Physics - Thermodynamics: Comprehension Passage

A thermally insulating cylinder has a thermally insulating and frictionless movable partition in the middle, as shown in the figure below. On each side of the partition, there is one mole of an ideal gas, with specific heat at constant volume, . Here, R is the gas constant. Initially, each side has a volume and temperature . The left side has an electric heater, which is turned on at very low power to transfer heat Q to the gas on the left side. As a result the partition moves slowly towards the right reducing the right side volume to . Consequently, the gas temperatures on the left and the right sides become and , respectively. Ignore the changes in the temperatures of the cylinder, heater and the partition.
Question 1:

The value of is

Select Answer:

Question 2:

The value of is

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

  • Two identical chambers separated by an insulating, frictionless partition.
  • Initial state for both sides: .
  • Heat is supplied slowly to the left chamber.

  • The partition is thermally insulating.
  • The partition moves slowly Reversible process.
  • Therefore, the right gas undergoes a Reversible Adiabatic Compression.

  • Specific heat at constant volume:
  • Gas constant:
  • Adiabatic exponent:

  • Adiabatic equation:
  • Final volume of right gas:

  • The partition moves slowly, meaning the system is always in mechanical equilibrium.
  • Final pressure of left gas = Final pressure of right gas

  • Adiabatic equation for right gas:

  • Total volume is constant:
  • Ideal gas law for left gas:

  • Apply the First Law to the entire system (Left + Right gas).
  • The outer cylinder is rigid, so total volume change is zero.

  • If the partition was thermally conducting, heat would flow until .
  • The process for the right gas would no longer be adiabatic.
  • The final state would be determined by and .

The Sigma Insight: First Law of Thermodynamics

Solution Diagram
Imagine a perfectly insulated cylinder divided equally by a movable partition. Both sides start in perfect harmony: same temperature, same volume, same pressure. But then, we turn on a heater in the left chamber. This is where the physics begins.

The Right Chamber

A Reversible Adiabatic Journey
As the left gas heats up, it expands, pushing the partition to the right. Notice that the partition is explicitly stated to be insulating and moves very slowly. What does this mean for the right gas? It's being compressed without any heat exchange. This is a classic reversible adiabatic process.
To analyze this adiabatic compression, we first need the adiabatic exponent, . We are given the specific heat at constant volume as . Using the fundamental relation , we find that .
Now, let's connect the initial and final states of the right gas. For an adiabatic process, the product of temperature and volume to the power is constant:
We substitute the initial volume and the final volume :
Solving this, the terms cancel out beautifully, leaving us with . So, the ratio of to is simply . That's our answer for the first part of the problem!

The Left Chamber

Mechanical Equilibrium
Let's shift our focus to the left gas. Because the partition moves slowly, the forces on it are always balanced. This means the pressure on the left side is always equal to the pressure on the right side. They reach the same final pressure, .
To find this final pressure, we can again use the right gas. For an adiabatic process, pressure times volume to the power is constant:
Substituting the volumes, we find the final pressure:
Now we have everything we need for the left gas. The total volume is fixed at , so the left gas must occupy a volume of . Using the ideal gas equation, we can set up a ratio to find its final temperature:
Substituting the values of final pressure and final volume:
Notice how much hotter it is compared to the right side!

The Grand Finale

The First Law of Thermodynamics
We are finally ready to find the total heat supplied, . The smartest way is to apply the First Law of Thermodynamics to the entire system as a whole. Since the outer cylinder is rigid, the total work done by the combined gases is zero (). So, all the heat goes into changing the total internal energy:
Let's calculate the change in internal energy for both sides. For an ideal gas, it's simply . We plug in the temperatures we just found:
Adding them up, we combine the terms and the constant terms:
Factoring out a , we arrive at our final expression:
The ratio is exactly . We've elegantly solved a complex thermodynamic puzzle by breaking it down into manageable, logical steps!

Similar Questions

JEE Advanced 2014
LEVELJEE Advanced

Comprehension Passage

In the figure a container is shown to have a movable (without friction) piston on top. The container and the piston are all made of perfectly insulating material allowing no heat transfer between outside and inside the container. The container is divided into two compartments by a rigid partition made of a thermally conducting material that allows slow transfer of heat. The lower compartment of the container is filled with 2 moles of an ideal monoatomic gas at 700 K and the upper compartment is filled with 2 moles of an ideal diatomic gas at 400 K. The heat capacities per mole of an ideal monoatomic gas are , and those for an ideal diatomic gas are .
Question 1:

Consider the partition to be rigidly fixed so that it does not move. When equilibrium is achieved, the final temperature of the gases will be

(A)
550 K
(B)
525 K
(C)
513 K
(D)
490 K
Question 2:

Now consider the partition to be free to move without friction so that the pressure of gases in both compartments is the same. Then total work done by the gases till the time they achieve equilibrium will be

(A)
250R
(B)
200R
(C)
100R
(D)
-100R
LEVELJEE Advanced

Comprehension Passage

A sample of 2 kg monoatomic helium (assumed ideal) is taken through the process and another sample of 2 kg of the same gas is taken through the process (see fig). Given molecular mass of helium = 4.
Question 1:

(a) What is the temperature of helium in each of the states and ?

Question 2:

(b) Is there any way of telling afterwards which sample of helium went through the process and which went through the process ? Write Yes or No.

Question 3:

(c) How much is the heat involved in the process and ?

LEVELJEE Main

An insulated container of gas has two chambers separated by an insulating partition. One of the chambers has volume and contains ideal gas at pressure and temperature . The other chamber has volume and contains ideal gas at pressure and temperature . If the partition is removed without doing any work on the gas, the final equilibrium temperature of the gas in the container will be

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Advanced 2026
LEVELJEE Advanced

As shown in the figure, an insulated container is fitted with a thermally conducting but immovable partition () and a freely movable but thermally insulated piston (). The partition with thermal conductivity , cross sectional area and width divides the container into two sections, and , each containing one mole of a monoatomic gas. The piston moves freely such that the gas in is always at the atmospheric pressure. Initially, the difference between the temperatures of and is . The time it takes for the temperature difference to become is , where is the universal gas constant. The value of is: [Given: ]

LEVELJEE Main

A container with insulating walls is divided into two equal parts by a partition fitted with a valve. One part is filled with an ideal gas at a pressure and temperature , whereas the other part is completely evacuated. If the valve is suddenly opened, the pressure and temperature of the gas will be

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Advanced 2014
LEVELJEE Main

An ideal gas in thermally insulated vessel at internal pressure = , volume = and absolute temperature = expands irrversibly against zero external pressure, as shown in the diagram. The final internal pressure, volume and absolute temperature of the gas are , and , respectively. For this expansion,

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
LEVELJEE Main

A thermally insulated vessel contains an ideal gas of molecular mass and ratio of specific heats . It is moving with speed and its suddenly brought to rest. Assuming no heat is lost to the surroundings, its temperature increases by

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Advanced 2018
LEVELJEE Advanced

A reversible cyclic process for an ideal gas is shown below. Here, P , V and T are pressure , volume and temperature , respectively. The thermodynamic parameters q, w, H and U are heat, work, enthalpy and internal energy, respectively.

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
and
(B)
and
(C)
and
(D)
and
JEE Advanced 2015
LEVELJEE Advanced

An ideal monoatomic gas is confined in a horizontal cylinder by a spring loaded piston (as shown in the figure). Initially the gas is at temperature , pressure and volume and the spring is in its relaxed state. The gas is then heated very slowly to temperature , pressure and volume . During this process the piston moves out by a distance . Ignoring the friction between the piston and the cylinder, the correct statements is/are

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
If and , then the energy stored in the spring is
(B)
If and , then the change in internal energy is
(C)
If and , then the work done by the gas is
(D)
If and , then the heat supplied to the gas is
JEE Advanced 2020
LEVELJEE Advanced

A thermally isolated cylindrical closed vessel of height 8 m is kept vertically. It is divided into two equal parts by a diathermic (perfect thermal conductor) frictionless partition of mass 8.3 kg. Thus the partition is held initially at a distance of 4 m from the top, as shown in the schematic figure below. Each of the two parts of the vessel contains 0.1 mole of an ideal gas at temperature 300 K. The partition is now released and moves without any gas leaking from one part of the vessel to the other. When equilibrium is reached, the distance of the partition from the top (in m) will be ______. (take the acceleration due to gravity = 10 ms^{-2} and the universal gas constant = 8.3 J mol^{-1} K^{-1}).