Animated Solution for Physics - Thermodynamics: Comprehension Passage
A thermally insulating cylinder has a thermally insulating and frictionless movable partition in the middle, as shown in the figure below. On each side of the partition, there is one mole of an ideal gas, with specific heat at constant volume, CV=2R. Here, R is the gas constant. Initially, each side has a volume V0 and temperature T0. The left side has an electric heater, which is turned on at very low power to transfer heat Q to the gas on the left side. As a result the partition moves slowly towards the right reducing the right side volume to V0/2. Consequently, the gas temperatures on the left and the right sides become TL and TR, respectively. Ignore the changes in the temperatures of the cylinder, heater and the partition.
Question 1:
The value of T0TR is
Select Answer:
Question 2:
The value of RT0Q is
Select Answer:
Visualized Solution
InitialStateoftheSystem
Two identical chambers separated by an insulating, frictionless partition.
Initial state for both sides: T0,V0,P0.
Heat Q is supplied slowly to the left chamber.
ProcessfortheRightGas
The partition is thermally insulating.
The partition moves slowly ⟹ Reversible process.
Therefore, the right gas undergoes a Reversible Adiabatic Compression.
AdiabaticExponent(γ)
Specific heat at constant volume: CV=2R
Gas constant: R=CP−CV
Adiabatic exponent: γ=CVCP=1+CVR
γ=1+2RR=23
TemperatureofRightGas(TR)
Adiabatic equation: TVγ−1=constant
T0V0γ−1=TRVRγ−1
Final volume of right gas: VR=2V0
T0V01/2=TR(2V0)1/2
RatioofTemperatures
TR=T0(V0/2V0)1/2
TR=T0(2)1/2=2T0
T0TR=2
MechanicalEquilibrium
The partition moves slowly, meaning the system is always in mechanical equilibrium.
Final pressure of left gas = Final pressure of right gas
PL=PR=Pf
FinalPressure(Pf)
Adiabatic equation for right gas: PVγ=constant
P0V0γ=PfVRγ
Pf=P0(V0/2V0)3/2
Pf=P0(2)3/2=22P0
TemperatureofLeftGas(TL)
Total volume is constant: VL+VR=2V0
VL=2V0−2V0=23V0
Ideal gas law for left gas: TLPfVL=T0P0V0
TL=T0P0PfV0VL
CalculatingTL
TL=T0(P022P0)(V03V0/2)
TL=T0(22)(23)
TL=32T0
FirstLawofThermodynamics
Apply the First Law to the entire system (Left + Right gas).
Qtotal=ΔUtotal+Wtotal
The outer cylinder is rigid, so total volume change is zero.
Wtotal=0
Q=ΔUL+ΔUR
ChangeinInternalEnergy
ΔU=nCVΔT
ΔUL=(1)(2R)(TL−T0)=2R(32T0−T0)
ΔUR=(1)(2R)(TR−T0)=2R(2T0−T0)
Q=2RT0(32−1)+2RT0(2−1)
TotalHeatSupplied(Q)
Q=2RT0[(32−1)+(2−1)]
Q=2RT0[42−2]
Q=4RT0(22−1)
RT0Q=4(22−1)
Whatifthepartitionwasconducting?
If the partition was thermally conducting, heat would flow until TL=TR.
The process for the right gas would no longer be adiabatic.
The final state would be determined by TL=TR and PL=PR.
00:00 / 00:00
The Sigma Insight: First Law of Thermodynamics
Solution Diagram
Imagine a perfectly insulated cylinder divided equally by a movable partition. Both sides start in perfect harmony: same temperature, same volume, same pressure. But then, we turn on a heater in the left chamber. This is where the physics begins.
The Right Chamber
A Reversible Adiabatic Journey
As the left gas heats up, it expands, pushing the partition to the right. Notice that the partition is explicitly stated to be insulating and moves very slowly. What does this mean for the right gas? It's being compressed without any heat exchange. This is a classic reversible adiabatic process.
To analyze this adiabatic compression, we first need the adiabatic exponent, γ. We are given the specific heat at constant volume as CV=2R. Using the fundamental relation γ=1+CVR, we find that γ=1+2RR=23.
Now, let's connect the initial and final states of the right gas. For an adiabatic process, the product of temperature and volume to the power γ−1 is constant:
T0V0γ−1=TRVRγ−1
We substitute the initial volume V0 and the final volume VR=2V0:
T0V01/2=TR(2V0)1/2
Solving this, the V0 terms cancel out beautifully, leaving us with TR=2T0. So, the ratio of TR to T0 is simply 2. That's our answer for the first part of the problem!
The Left Chamber
Mechanical Equilibrium
Let's shift our focus to the left gas. Because the partition moves slowly, the forces on it are always balanced. This means the pressure on the left side is always equal to the pressure on the right side. They reach the same final pressure, Pf.
To find this final pressure, we can again use the right gas. For an adiabatic process, pressure times volume to the power γ is constant:
P0V0γ=PfVRγ
Substituting the volumes, we find the final pressure:
Pf=P0(V0/2V0)3/2=22P0
Now we have everything we need for the left gas. The total volume is fixed at 2V0, so the left gas must occupy a volume of VL=2V0−2V0=23V0. Using the ideal gas equation, we can set up a ratio to find its final temperature:
TLPfVL=T0P0V0
Substituting the values of final pressure and final volume:
TL=T0(P022P0)(V03V0/2)=32T0
Notice how much hotter it is compared to the right side!
The Grand Finale
The First Law of Thermodynamics
We are finally ready to find the total heat supplied, Q. The smartest way is to apply the First Law of Thermodynamics to the entire system as a whole. Since the outer cylinder is rigid, the total work done by the combined gases is zero (Wtotal=0). So, all the heat goes into changing the total internal energy:
Q=ΔUL+ΔUR
Let's calculate the change in internal energy for both sides. For an ideal gas, it's simply nCVΔT. We plug in the temperatures we just found:
ΔUL=(1)(2R)(32T0−T0)=2RT0(32−1)
ΔUR=(1)(2R)(2T0−T0)=2RT0(2−1)
Adding them up, we combine the 2 terms and the constant terms:
Q=2RT0[(32−1)+(2−1)]=2RT0[42−2]
Factoring out a 2, we arrive at our final expression:
Q=4RT0(22−1)
The ratio RT0Q is exactly 4(22−1). We've elegantly solved a complex thermodynamic puzzle by breaking it down into manageable, logical steps!