Animated Solution for Physics - Kinematics: A small ball is thrown from foot of a wall with the minimum possible velocity to hit a bulb B on the ground a distance L away from the wall. Find expression for height h of shadow of the ball on the wall as a function of time t. Acceleration due to gravity is g.
Visualized Solution
Problem Setup
Let the foot of the wall be the origin (0,0).
The wall lies along the y-axis.
The bulb B is on the ground at (L,0).
Minimum Velocity Condition
For a given range R=L, the minimum projection velocity u occurs at an angle θ=45∘.
R=gu2sin2θ⟹L=gu2sin90∘
Initial Velocity Components
u2=gL⟹u=gL
ux=ucos45∘=2gL
uy=usin45∘=2gL
Coordinates of the Ball
At any time t, the position (x,y) of the ball is:
x(t)=uxt=t2gL
y(t)=uyt−21gt2=t2gL−21gt2
Shadow Formation
The shadow is formed on the wall (0,h) by the light ray from the bulb (L,0) passing through the ball (x,y).
Therefore, the points (L,0), (x,y), and (0,h) are collinear.
Collinearity Condition
Equating the slopes of the line segments:
m=0−Lh−0=x−Ly−0
−Lh=x−Ly⟹h=L−xLy
Substituting Coordinates
Substitute x(t) and y(t) into the height equation:
h=L−t2gLL(t2gL−21gt2)
Simplifying the Expression
Factor out t2g from the numerator:
y(t)=t2g(L−t2g)
Factor out L from the denominator:
L−x(t)=L(L−t2g)
Final Expression for Height
The common term (L−t2g) cancels out:
h(t)=LL⋅t2g=t2gL
The shadow moves with a constant velocity!
00:00 / 00:00
The Sigma Insight: Projectile Motion
Solution Diagram
The Constant Velocity Shadow of a Parabolic Projectile
Physics is often full of beautiful surprises where complex, accelerating motions perfectly align to create something incredibly simple. This problem is a classic example of such mathematical elegance, blending the kinematics of a projectile with the coordinate geometry of straight lines.
The Physics of the Throw
Imagine you are standing at the foot of a wall (the origin, x=0,y=0) and you need to throw a ball to hit a bulb resting on the ground at a distance L away (coordinates L,0). The problem imposes a strict condition: you must use the minimum possible velocity.
From the standard projectile range formula, R=gu2sin(2θ), we know that to achieve a given range R=L with the smallest possible initial speed u, we must maximize the sine function. This happens when sin(2θ)=1, which means the angle of projection must be exactly θ=45∘.
Plugging this back in, we find the initial velocity squared is u2=gL, giving u=gL. Because the angle is 45∘, the horizontal and vertical components of this velocity are identical:
ux=ucos45∘=2gL
uy=usin45∘=2gL
Tracking the Ball
With the initial velocities locked in, we can write down the exact coordinates of the ball (x,y) at any given time t using the equations of motion:
x(t)=t2gL
y(t)=t2gL−21gt2
The Geometry of the Shadow
Now comes the crucial geometric insight. How is the shadow formed on the wall? A light ray originates from the bulb at (L,0), travels in a perfectly straight line, passes exactly through the ball at (x,y), and strikes the wall at a height (0,h).
Because light travels in straight lines, these three points—the bulb, the ball, and the shadow—must be collinear. This means the slope of the line segment connecting the shadow to the bulb is identical to the slope of the line segment connecting the ball to the bulb.
Equating the slopes:
0−Lh−0=x−Ly−0
Rearranging this gives us a direct expression for the shadow's height:
h=L−xLy
The Mathematical Magic
We now substitute our time-dependent expressions for x(t) and y(t) into this geometric relation:
h=L−t2gLL(t2gL−21gt2)
At first glance, this looks like a messy, non-linear function of time. But let's factor it carefully. In the numerator, we can pull out t2g:
Numerator=L⋅t2g(L−t2g)
In the denominator, we can factor out L:
Denominator=L(L−t2g)
Notice the magic? The entire complex bracket (L−t2g) appears in both the numerator and the denominator. It cancels out perfectly!
Conclusion
After the cancellation, we are left with a stunningly simple result:
h(t)=t2gL
The height of the shadow is directly proportional to time t. This means that while the ball is undergoing a complex parabolic trajectory, constantly accelerating downwards due to gravity, its shadow is marching up the wall with a perfectly constant velocity of vh=2gL. It is a beautiful reminder of how underlying symmetries in physics can lead to incredibly elegant outcomes.