Animated Solution for Physics - Rotational Motion: Consider a situation in which a ring, a solid cylinder and a solid sphere roll down on the same inclined plane without slipping. Assume that they start rolling from rest and having identical diameter. The correct statement for this situation.
Select Answer:
Visualized Solution
\text{Rolling on an Inclined Plane}
Three bodies: Ring, Solid Cylinder, Solid Sphere
Released from rest on an inclined plane of height h
\text{Conservation of Energy}
Total Energy at Top=Total Energy at Bottom
mgh=21mv2+21Iω2
\text{Radius of Gyration}
Let I=mk2 where k is the radius of gyration.
For pure rolling, ω=Rv
mgh=21mv2+21(mk2)(Rv)2
\text{Velocity Formula}
mgh=21mv2(1+R2k2)
v=1+R2k22gh
\text{Velocity of Ring}
For a ring, I=mR2⟹k2=R2⟹R2k2=1
vring=1+12gh=gh
\text{Velocity of Solid Cylinder}
For a solid cylinder, I=21mR2⟹R2k2=21
vcyl=1+1/22gh=34gh≈1.33gh
\text{Velocity of Solid Sphere}
For a solid sphere, I=52mR2⟹R2k2=52
vsph=1+2/52gh=710gh≈1.43gh
\text{Conclusion}
vsph>vcyl>vring
Sphere has the greatest velocity, ring has the least.
00:00 / 00:00
The Sigma Insight: Rolling Motion
Solution Diagram
The Race of the Rolling Bodies
Imagine you are standing at the top of a steep hill, holding three objects: a ring, a solid cylinder, and a solid sphere. They all have the exact same mass and the exact same radius. You release them at the exact same time. They roll down the hill without slipping. Which one reaches the bottom first? Which one is moving the fastest when it crosses the finish line?
This is a classic physics race, and the winner isn't determined by weight or size, but by how their mass is distributed! Let's dive into the beautiful physics of rolling motion to find out who takes the gold medal.
The Energy Exchange
To solve this, we need to look at the energy of the system. At the top of the incline, all three bodies are at rest. They possess only gravitational potential energy, given by mgh, where h is the height of the incline.
As they roll down, this potential energy is converted into kinetic energy. But here is the catch: because they are rolling without slipping, they aren't just moving forward (translating); they are also spinning (rotating). Therefore, the total kinetic energy at the bottom is the sum of translational kinetic energy and rotational kinetic energy.
mgh=21mv2+21Iω2
Here, v is the linear velocity of the center of mass, I is the moment of inertia, and ω is the angular velocity.
The Master Equation
We can simplify this equation to make it easier to compare the three bodies. First, we can express the moment of inertia I in terms of the radius of gyration k, such that I=mk2. The radius of gyration is simply a measure of how far the mass is distributed from the center.
Second, because the bodies are rolling without slipping, the linear velocity and angular velocity are perfectly locked together by the relation v=ωR, or ω=Rv.
Substituting these into our energy equation:
mgh=21mv2+21(mk2)(Rv)2
Notice how the mass m cancels out completely! This means a heavy sphere and a light sphere will roll down at the exact same speed. Factoring out the velocity v, we get:
gh=21v2(1+R2k2)
Solving for the final velocity v, we arrive at our master equation:
v=1+R2k22gh
This equation tells us a profound truth: the final velocity depends entirely on the factor R2k2. The smaller this factor, the smaller the denominator, and the larger the final velocity!
The Final Verdict
Now, let's calculate this factor for each of our competitors.
1. The Ring:
A ring has all its mass concentrated at its outer edge. Its moment of inertia is I=mR2. Therefore, k2=R2, and the factor R2k2=1.
vring=1+12gh=gh
2. The Solid Cylinder:
A solid cylinder has its mass spread evenly throughout its volume. Its moment of inertia is I=21mR2. Therefore, the factor R2k2=21.
vcyl=1+1/22gh=34gh≈1.33gh
3. The Solid Sphere:
A solid sphere has its mass concentrated closest to its center compared to the other two. Its moment of inertia is I=52mR2. Therefore, the factor R2k2=52.
vsph=1+2/52gh=710gh≈1.43gh
Comparing the results, we see that vsph>vcyl>vring.
The solid sphere wins the race! Because its mass is concentrated closer to the center, it has the smallest moment of inertia. It requires less energy to spin, leaving more of the initial potential energy to be converted into pure, forward speed. The ring, on the other hand, is the hardest to spin, so it ends up being the slowest.