Visualizing the Setup
Imagine a concave mirror resting on the principal axis
We are given an object placed beyond the center of curvature C. From our basic ray optics intuition, we know that when an object is placed beyond C, its real and inverted image forms between the center of curvature C and the principal focus F.
The problem gives us distances relative to the center of curvature C: the object is at a distance d1 from C, and the image is at a distance d2 from C. To use our standard mirror formula, we must translate these relative distances into absolute coordinates measured from the pole P.
Setting Up the Geometry
Let the radius of curvature of the mirror be R
According to the Cartesian sign convention, since the object is placed in front of the reflecting surface, all our measurements will be negative.
The object distance u is the distance from P to C plus the extra distance d1. Thus, u=−(R+d1).
The image distance v is the distance from P to C minus the distance d2 (since the image is between C and F). Thus, v=−(R−d2).
The focal length of a concave mirror is half its radius of curvature, so f=−2R.
The Magic of Algebra
We start with the classic mirror formula:
f1=v1+u1
To make the algebra cleaner, let's rearrange it to avoid dealing with reciprocals immediately:
uv=f(u+v)
Now, we substitute our carefully crafted expressions into this rearranged formula:
[−(R+d1)][−(R−d2)]=−2R[−(R+d1)−(R−d2)]
The negative signs on the left side multiply to give a positive product. On the right side, we can factor out the negative sign from the bracket:
(R+d1)(R−d2)=−2R[−2R−d1+d2]
Let's multiply the entire equation by 2 to eliminate the fraction, and expand the brackets:
2(R2−Rd2+Rd1−d1d2)=R(2R+d1−d2)
2R2+2R(d1−d2)−2d1d2=2R2+R(d1−d2)
The Final Elegance
Notice how the 2R2 terms on both sides perfectly cancel each other out! This is the beauty of physics equations; they often collapse into elegant forms.
Let's group the remaining terms containing
R on the left side, and move the
d1d2 term to the right:
2R(d1−d2)−R(d1−d2)=2d1d2
R(d1−d2)=2d1d2
Finally, isolating
R, we get our answer:
R=d1−d22d1d2
Pro Tip: This entire problem can be solved in just two lines using Newton's Formula, x1x2=f2, where x1 and x2 are the distances of the object and image from the focus F. Try it out yourself to see how powerful alternative frameworks can be!