Sigma Percentile
JEE Advanced 2000
LEVELJEE Main

Animated Solution for Mathematics - Limits, Continuity and Differentiability: Let be any function. Define by for all . Then is

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

  • Given function:
  • Defined function:
  • We need to determine which property of is always inherited by .

  • To test the options, let's pick a simple, well-behaved function.
  • Let .
  • This function is continuous, differentiable, one-one, and onto.

  • The modulus operation reflects the negative part of the graph above the x-axis.

  • We know is continuous.
  • The absolute value function is also continuous.
  • is a composition of two continuous functions.
  • Therefore, is always continuous.

  • Look at the point on the graph of .
  • There is a sharp corner or kink at the origin.
  • A function is not differentiable at sharp corners.

  • Left Hand Derivative (LHD) at :
  • Right Hand Derivative (RHD) at :
  • Since , is not differentiable.

  • A function is one-one if every output has exactly one unique input.
  • Visually, we use the Horizontal Line Test.
  • If any horizontal line intersects the graph more than once, it is not one-one.

  • For , let's draw a line .
  • It intersects the graph at and .
  • and .
  • Thus, is many-one, not one-one.

  • A function is onto if its range equals its codomain ().
  • The output of an absolute value function is always non-negative: .
  • The range is , which is not equal to .

  • Look at the region below the x-axis.
  • There is no part of the graph in the negative y-region.
  • Negative real numbers have no pre-image.
  • Thus, is not onto.

  • is not necessarily differentiable, one-one, or onto.
  • However, the composition of continuous functions is always continuous.
  • Correct Answer: is continuous if is continuous.

The Sigma Insight: Continuity at a Point and in an Interval

Solution Diagram

Analyzing the Setup

Welcome, future engineer! Today, we are going to explore a problem that seems simple on the surface but hides deep conceptual truths about the nature of functions. We are given a function and a new function .
Our goal is to determine which property of is always inherited by . This is not just about finding the right option; it is about understanding how transformations reshape the landscape of a function.

The Modulus

A Mirror in the Coordinate Plane
Imagine you are standing in front of a mirror. The modulus function acts exactly like a mirror placed along the x-axis.
Any part of the graph of that lies below the x-axis is reflected upwards, becoming positive. This simple geometric act of reflection is powerful, but it comes with consequences.
It can turn a smooth curve into a jagged one, or it can collapse two distinct inputs into the same output. Let us investigate this using the most elegant tool in our arsenal: the counter-example.

The Power of the Counter-Example

When faced with a general function , the best strategy is to test it with a simple, well-behaved function. Let us choose .
This function is the gold standard: it is continuous, differentiable, one-one, and onto. Now, let us see what happens when we apply the modulus transformation to it. We get .

Why 'Onto' and 'One-One' Crumble

First, let us check if is onto. For a function to be onto, its range must equal its codomain, which is .
But look at the graph of . It never dips below the x-axis. Its range is .
All the negative real numbers in the codomain are left without a pre-image. Thus, the modulus transformation has destroyed the 'onto' property.
Next, let us check if it is one-one. A function is one-one if every output comes from a unique input. Consider and .
Since two different inputs produce the same output, the function is many-one, not one-one. The mirror effect has collapsed the negative side onto the positive side, destroying injectivity.

The Sharp Corner of Non-Differentiability

Now, let us address the most subtle trap: differentiability. We know is differentiable everywhere.
But look at at the origin, . There is a sharp 'V' shape, a kink. Mathematically, the left-hand derivative and right-hand derivative are calculated as follows:
Because the slopes from the left and right do not match, the function is not differentiable at . The modulus transformation has introduced a point of non-differentiability where none existed before.

The Unbreakable Bond of Continuity

Finally, we arrive at continuity. If is continuous, then is the composition of two continuous functions: the function and the absolute value function .
Since the absolute value function is continuous everywhere, the composition must also be continuous. There are no jumps, no breaks, and no gaps.
The continuity is preserved. This is the only property that survives the transformation unscathed. We have successfully navigated the traps and arrived at the truth: is continuous if is continuous.

Similar Questions

JEE Main 2021 (16 March Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Main

Let and be defined as and where are non-negative real numbers. If is continuous for all , then is equal to ____

JEE Main 2021 (20 July Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Let a function be defined as Where is the greatest integer less than or equal to . If is continuous on , then is equal to:

(A)
4
(B)
3
(C)
2
(D)
5
JEE Main 2020 - 7 Jan (Evening)
LEVELJEE Main

If the function defined on by is continuous, then is equal to . . . .

JEE Advanced 1989
LEVELJEE Main

If , then on the interval

(A)
and are both continuous
(B)
and are both discontinuous
(C)
and are both continuous
(D)
is continuous but is not
JEE Advanced 2014
LEVELJEE Main

For every pair of continuous functions such that , the correct statement(s) is (are):

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
for some
(B)
for some
(C)
for some
(D)
for some
JEE Advanced 1981
LEVELJEE Main

Let for all and . If the function is continuous at , then show that is continuous at all .

JEE Advanced 2012
LEVELJEE Main

For every integer , let and be real numbers. Let function be given by for all integers . If is continuous, then which of the following hold(s) for all ?

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2023 (11 Apr Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Let , where and denotes the greatest integer less than or equal to . Then, is

(A)
continuous at , but not continuous at
(B)
continuous at , but not continuous at
(C)
continuous at and
(D)
not continuous at and
JEE Main 2021 (February)
LEVELJEE Main

Let be defined as If is continuous on , then equals :

(A)
3
(B)
-1
(C)
-3
(D)
1
JEE Main 2026 (23 January Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Main

If is continuous at , then is equal to

(A)
4
(B)
1
(C)
2
(D)
0