The problem of mixing steam and ice is a classic battle of heat exchange. On one side, we have scorching hot steam ready to release a massive amount of energy. On the other side, we have freezing ice, hungry to absorb that energy to warm up and melt. Our goal is to find the final equilibrium state of this mixture.
The Calorimetry Battlefield
According to the principle of calorimetry, in an insulated vessel, the heat lost by the hot body must exactly equal the heat gained by the cold body.
Because water undergoes phase changes at 273 K (melting/freezing) and 373 K (boiling/condensation), we can't just plug numbers into a single equation. Instead, we must evaluate the heat exchange step-by-step, using 273 K as our primary checkpoint.
Analyzing the Heat Source
Steam
Let's determine the maximum heat the steam can provide if it cools all the way down to 273 K.
Step 1: Condensation of Steam
First, the 50 g of steam at 373 K condenses into water at 373 K. The heat released (Q1) depends on the latent heat of vaporization (Lvap=540 cal/g).
Q1=msteam×Lvap
Q1=50 g×540 cal/g=27000 cal=27 kcal
Step 2: Cooling the Hot Water
Next, this newly formed 50 g of hot water cools from 373 K to 273 K. The heat released (Q2) depends on the specific heat of water (Swater=1 cal/g-K).
Q2=mwater×Swater×ΔT
Q2=50 g×1 cal/g-K×(373 K−273 K)
Q2=50×100=5000 cal=5 kcal
Total Heat Available:
The total heat the steam can provide to reach
273 K is:
Qavailable=Q1+Q2=27 kcal+5 kcal=32 kcal
Analyzing the Heat Sink
Ice
Now, let's see how much heat the ice needs to reach 273 K and melt completely.
Step 3: Warming the Ice
The 450 g of ice must first warm from 253 K to 273 K. The heat required (Q3) depends on the specific heat of ice (Sice=0.5 cal/g-K).
Q3=mice×Sice×ΔT
Q3=450 g×0.5 cal/g-K×(273 K−253 K)
Q3=450×0.5×20=4500 cal=4.5 kcal
Step 4: Melting the Ice
To completely melt the 450 g of ice at 273 K into water, the heat required (Q4) depends on the latent heat of fusion (Lfusion=80 cal/g).
Q4=mice×Lfusion
Q4=450 g×80 cal/g=36000 cal=36 kcal
Total Heat Required:
The total heat required to completely melt the ice is:
Qrequired=Q3+Q4=4.5 kcal+36 kcal=40.5 kcal
The Grand Heat Balance
Now we compare the heat available with the heat required:
- Heat available from steam: 32 kcal
- Heat required to warm ice: 4.5 kcal
- Heat required to melt all ice: 40.5 kcal
Since 32 kcal>4.5 kcal, the steam provides more than enough heat to warm the ice to 273 K.
However, since 32 kcal<40.5 kcal, the steam does not provide enough heat to melt all the ice.
The Final Verdict
Because the available heat is exhausted while the ice is melting, the phase change is incomplete. The final mixture will consist of both water and unmelted ice coexisting in thermal equilibrium.
Whenever ice and water coexist in equilibrium, the temperature of the mixture is exactly the melting point. Therefore, the final temperature of the mixture is 273 K.