Sigma Percentile
JEE Advanced 1986
LEVELJEE Main

Animated Solution for Mathematics - Sequence and Series: If and are distinct positive numbers, then the expression is

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

Analyzing the Expression

  • We need to find the sign of .
  • Given are distinct positive numbers.
  • Direct expansion is too complex. We need a smart substitution.

The Substitution Trick

  • Let
  • Let
  • Let
  • The expression simplifies to .

Expressing in terms of and

  • Let's add and :
  • Therefore,

Expressing and

  • By symmetry, adding and gives:
  • Adding and gives:

Checking the Signs of

  • Can be negative?
  • If two were negative, say and :
  • .
  • But is positive! So at most one variable can be negative.

Case 1: One Variable is Negative

  • Suppose exactly one variable is negative (e.g., ).
  • Then the product is negative.
  • Since are positive, is positive.
  • Thus, (Negative).

Case 2: All Variables are Positive

  • What if are all positive?
  • We can apply the AM-GM inequality.
  • For distinct positive numbers: Arithmetic Mean Geometric Mean.

Applying AM-GM to all pairs

  • Since , we have
  • Similarly,
  • And

Multiplying the Inequalities

  • Multiply the three inequalities:

The Final Conclusion

  • We established that .
  • Our original expression is equivalent to .
  • Since , the difference must be less than zero.
  • Therefore, the expression is always negative.

The Sigma Insight: Relation Between A.M., G.M., and H.M.

Solution Diagram

Analyzing the Setup

The expression provided is . At first glance, this appears to be a complex algebraic knot, but it possesses a deep, underlying symmetry.

The Substitution Bridge

To simplify the expression, we employ the Substitution Bridge. We define the following variables:
This transformation simplifies the expression to . To relate these back to the original variables, we solve for , , and :

The Reality Check

We must consider the signs of , , and . If two variables were negative, their sum would be negative, implying that , , and are negative, which contradicts the standard premise of such problems.
Therefore, at most one variable can be negative. If one variable is negative, the product becomes negative, and since is positive, the entire expression is clearly negative.

The AM-GM Engine

When , we utilize the Arithmetic Mean-Geometric Mean (AM-GM) Inequality. Since , the inequality dictates:
By symmetry, we can establish the same relationship for the other variables:
Multiplying these three inequalities together yields:
This simplifies to . Consequently, it follows that:

Conclusion

Through the application of symmetry, substitution, and the power of inequalities, we have demonstrated that the expression is always negative. When encountering symmetric expressions in the JEE Advanced exam, look for these substitutions to simplify the structure and let the inequalities perform the heavy lifting.

Similar Questions

JEE Advanced 2004
LEVELJEE Main

If are positive real numbers. Then prove that

JEE Advanced 1984
LEVELBoard

If and , prove that .

JEE Advanced 2002
LEVELBoard

If are positive real numbers whose product is a fixed number , then the minimum value of is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Advanced 1991
LEVELBoard

The product of positive numbers is unity Then their sum is

(A)
a positive integer
(B)
divisible by
(C)
equal to
(D)
never less than
JEE Advanced 2014
LEVELJEE Main

Let be positive integers such that is an integer. If are in geometric progression and the arithmetic mean of is , then the value of is \dots.

JEE Advanced 1982
LEVELJEE Main

If are any real numbers and is any positive integer, then

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
none of these
JEE Main 11 Jan 2019 (Evening)
LEVELBoard

Let be positive real numbers and positive integers. The maximum value of the expression is:

(A)
(B)
1
(C)
(D)
JEE Advanced 2000
LEVELJEE Main

If are positive real numbers such that , then satisfies the relation

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2023 (15 Apr Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Let and be two arithmetic means and and be three geometric means of two distinct positive numbers. Then is equal to

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Advanced 1988
LEVELJEE Main

If the first and the st terms of an A.P., a G.P. and an H.P. are equal and their th terms are and respectively, then

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)