Analyzing the Setup
Imagine you are building a battery. On the left side, you have a Zinc electrode sitting in a solution of its own ions. This is our anode, where oxidation happens. On the right side, you have a mystery metal M acting as the cathode, where reduction takes place.
The standard reduction potential of the Zinc anode is given as EZn2+/Zn∘=−0.76 V. Our mission is to choose the best cathode from a given list. But there is a twist! We are not just looking for the highest overall cell potential. We are looking for the maximum cell potential per electron transferred.
The Master Equation
To find the standard cell potential, we use the fundamental equation of electrochemistry:
Ecell∘=Ecathode∘−Eanode∘
Since Eanode∘=−0.76 V, the equation becomes:
Ecell∘=Ecathode∘−(−0.76)=Ecathode∘+0.76 V
However, the question specifically asks us to maximize the ratio nEcell∘, where n is the number of electrons transferred in the cathode half-reaction. Let's evaluate this ratio for each candidate.
Evaluating the Candidates
1. Gold (Au3+/Au)
The reduction potential is 1.40 V. The reaction is Au3++3e−→Au, so n=3.
Ecell∘=1.40−(−0.76)=2.16 V
2. Silver (Ag+/Ag)
The reduction potential is 0.80 V. The reaction is Ag++1e−→Ag, so n=1.
Ecell∘=0.80−(−0.76)=1.56 V
3. Iron(III) to Iron(II) (Fe3+/Fe2+)
The reduction potential is 0.77 V. The reaction is Fe3++1e−→Fe2+, so n=1.
Ecell∘=0.77−(−0.76)=1.53 V
4. Iron(II) to Iron (Fe2+/Fe)
The reduction potential is −0.44 V. The reaction is Fe2++2e−→Fe, so n=2.
Ecell∘=−0.44−(−0.76)=0.32 V
Final Conclusion
Comparing the calculated ratios, Silver (Ag+/Ag) yields the highest value of 1.56 V per electron transferred.
Notice how Gold had the highest total cell potential (2.16 V), but because it requires three electrons per atom of Gold deposited, its potential per electron is much lower. This highlights the importance of reading the question carefully to avoid falling into a trap!