The Optical Setup
Imagine a parallel beam of light traveling through the vastness of space. It first encounters a convex lens, A, which possesses a focal length of 20cm. Shortly after, the light is intercepted by a concave lens, B, with a focal length of 5cm. These two lenses are placed coaxially, separated by an unknown distance d.
Our objective is to determine this exact separation distance d, given a very specific and beautiful optical condition: the light that enters the system as a parallel beam must also exit the system as a perfectly parallel beam.
The Journey of the Rays
Let's trace the journey of the light step by step. When a parallel beam of light strikes a convex lens, the laws of optics dictate that it must converge. Specifically, the lens bends the rays so that they aim to meet at its second principal focus.
Since the focal length of lens A is 20cm, these rays are directed towards a point exactly 20cm behind lens A. Let's call this convergence point I1. If lens B were not there, the light would simply focus at I1 and then diverge again.
The Master Condition
However, before the rays can reach I1, they are intercepted by the concave lens B. The problem states a crucial condition: after passing through lens B, the rays become parallel once again.
Now, we must ask ourselves a fundamental question: When does a concave lens render converging rays parallel?
By the principle of reversibility of light, we know that parallel rays incident on a concave lens will diverge, appearing to originate from its first principal focus. Reversing this logic, if incident rays are converging exactly towards the first principal focus of a concave lens, the lens will bend them just enough to make them emerge parallel to the principal axis.
This is the master key to the problem! The point I1, which is the focus of the convex lens A, must simultaneously be the focus of the concave lens B. They share the exact same focal point in space.
The Geometric Conclusion
Since the focal length of lens B is 5cm, the distance from lens B to this shared focal point I1 must be exactly 5cm.
Now, let's look at the simple geometry of our setup along the principal axis. The total distance from lens A to the focus I1 is 20cm. The distance from lens B to the same focus I1 is 5cm. The distance d between the two lenses is simply the difference between these two values.
Substituting the given values:
Therefore, the two lenses must be separated by exactly 15cm to achieve this optical effect. It is a beautiful interplay of converging and diverging powers, perfectly balanced by their spatial separation!