Animated Solution for Physics - Kinematics: A boy starts from point A and passes point C of a track ABC shown in the figure. Portion AB of length l is straight and portion BC is a semicircle of radius r (r<l). Anywhere on the track, the modulus of the maximum acceleration of the boy is a. Find minimum transit time of the boy from A to C.
Visualized Solution
atot=at2+an2≤a
The track consists of a straight part AB of length l and a semicircle BC of radius r.
Total acceleration is bounded: atot=at2+an2≤a.
On AB, an=0⟹∣at∣≤a.
On BC, an=rv2⟹at2+(rv2)2≤a2.
vmax=ar
To minimize time, maximize speed v.
On BC, normal acceleration limits speed: rv2≤a⟹v≤ar.
Optimal strategy on BC: Maintain constant maximum speed v=ar.
Here, at=0 and an=a.
s1+s2=l
On AB, accelerate at maximum rate a to a peak speed vpeak.
Then, decelerate at maximum rate −a to reach B exactly at vB=ar.
Let s1 be the distance covered while accelerating.
Let s2 be the distance covered while decelerating.
Total distance: s1+s2=l.
s1−s2=2r
Acceleration phase: vpeak2=0+2as1.
Deceleration phase: vB2=vpeak2−2as2.
Substitute vB=ar:
ar=2as1−2as2
ar=2a(s1−s2)⟹s1−s2=2r.
vpeak=a(l+2r)
System of equations:
1) s1+s2=l
2) s1−s2=2r
Adding them: 2s1=l+2r⟹s1=42l+r.
Peak speed: vpeak=2as1=a(l+2r).
tAB=22a2l+r−ar
Time to accelerate: t1=avpeak.
Time to decelerate: t2=avpeak−vB.
Total time on AB: tAB=t1+t2=a2vpeak−vB.
Substitute vpeak and vB:
tAB=a2a(l+r/2)−ar=22a2l+r−ar.
tBC=πar
Length of semicircle BC is πr.
Speed is constant: v=ar.
Time on BC: tBC=SpeedDistance=arπr=πar.
T=(π−1)ar+22a2l+r
Total time T=tAB+tBC.
T=(22a2l+r−ar)+πar.
Grouping the ar terms:
T=(π−1)ar+22a2l+r.
\text{The Way Forward}
What if the straight path l was very short (l<r/2)?
The boy wouldn't have enough distance to reach the safe curve speed ar.
He would just accelerate all the way to B!
Optimizing trajectories under acceleration constraints is a fundamental problem in robotics and autonomous racing.
00:00 / 00:00
The Sigma Insight: Kinematics of Circular Motion
Solution Diagram
Imagine you are behind the wheel of a high-performance race car, or perhaps you are programming an autonomous drone. Your goal is simple: get from point A to point C in the absolute minimum time. But physics imposes a strict limit—your tires (or motors) can only provide a maximum total acceleration a. This problem is a beautiful exploration of how to balance speed, acceleration, and the geometry of your path to achieve the ultimate lap time.
Analyzing the Setup
The track is divided into two distinct segments. First, we have a straightaway AB of length l. Here, your path is linear, meaning you don't have to worry about turning. The only acceleration you experience is tangential (at), which changes your speed.
Second, we have a semicircular curve BC of radius r. On this curve, your velocity vector is constantly changing direction, which requires a normal (or centripetal) acceleration an=rv2 pointing towards the center of the curve.
The golden rule of this problem is that the vector sum of these accelerations cannot exceed a. Mathematically, this means:
atot=at2+an2≤a
Conquering the Curve
To minimize your overall time, you need to maintain the highest possible speed at all times. Let's look at the curved section BC first. Because you are turning, a portion of your acceleration budget must be dedicated to keeping you on the track. If you go too fast, the required normal acceleration rv2 will exceed your maximum limit a, and you will slide off!
To find the maximum safe speed on the curve, we dedicate all our acceleration to turning, setting an=a and at=0. This gives us:
rv2=a⟹v=ar
To traverse the semicircle as quickly as possible, you should enter point B at exactly this speed and maintain it constantly until you reach point C. Since the length of the semicircle is πr, the time spent on the curve is simply distance divided by speed:
tBC=arπr=πar
The Straightaway Strategy
Now, let's tackle the straight path AB. You start from rest at A. To cover the distance l quickly, you should slam on the accelerator and speed up at the maximum rate a. However, you can't just keep accelerating forever! You must arrive at point B with a speed no greater than the safe entry speed ar.
This means you must accelerate to a peak speed vpeak, and then hit the brakes, decelerating at the maximum rate −a so that you hit point B at exactly vB=ar.
Let s1 be the distance you spend accelerating, and s2 be the distance you spend braking. We know that the total distance is l:
s1+s2=l
The Math of the Straightaway
We can use the classic kinematic equation v2−u2=2as for both phases.
During the acceleration phase, starting from rest:
vpeak2=2as1
During the deceleration phase, ending at vB=ar:
vB2=vpeak2−2as2
Substituting vB2=ar and replacing vpeak2, we get a fascinating relationship:
ar=2as1−2as2⟹s1−s2=2r
We now have a simple system of linear equations. By adding s1+s2=l and s1−s2=2r, we can solve for the acceleration distance s1:
2s1=l+2r⟹s1=42l+r
This allows us to find the absolute maximum speed achieved on the straightaway:
vpeak=2as1=a(l+2r)
Final Calculation
With the peak speed known, calculating the time spent on the straightaway is straightforward. The time to accelerate is t1=avpeak, and the time to decelerate is t2=avpeak−vB. The total time on AB is their sum:
tAB=a2vpeak−vB
Substituting our expressions for vpeak and vB:
tAB=a2a(l+r/2)−ar=22a2l+r−ar
Finally, we add the time spent on the straightaway to the time spent on the curve to get the ultimate minimum transit time T:
T=tAB+tBC=(22a2l+r−ar)+πar
Grouping the common terms yields our elegant final answer:
T=(π−1)ar+22a2l+r
This result perfectly encapsulates the trade-off between straight-line speed and cornering limits, a principle that governs everything from Formula 1 racing to the trajectory planning of autonomous robots!