Sigma Percentile
JEE Main 2019
LEVELBoard

Animated Solution for Chemistry - Metallurgy: Assertion For the extraction of iron, haematite ore is used. Reason Heamatite is a carbonate ore of iron.

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

Problem Analysis

  • Assertion and Reason Analysis
  • Topic: Extraction of Iron

Analyzing Assertion

  • Assertion: For the extraction of iron, haematite ore is used.

Validating Assertion

  • Haematite is the principal ore of iron.
  • Assertion is True.

Analyzing Reason

  • Reason: Heamatite is a carbonate ore of iron.

Validating Reason

  • Carbonate ore of iron is Siderite ().
  • Reason is False.

Providing Correction

  • Haematite is an oxide ore.
  • Chemical formula:

Final Conclusion

  • Assertion is True.
  • Reason is False.
  • Correct Option: (d)

The Sigma Insight: Ores

Solution Diagram

Introduction to Metallurgy and Iron

Imagine standing before a towering blast furnace, feeling the immense heat radiating from its steel walls. This is where the magic of metallurgy happens. Iron, the absolute backbone of modern infrastructure, isn't found in its pure metallic form in nature. It loves oxygen way too much! Instead, it is found buried in the Earth's crust in the form of various minerals and ores.
To extract this precious metal, we must understand the chemical nature of these ores. This brings us to a classic Assertion-Reason problem that tests our fundamental knowledge of iron metallurgy. Let's break it down step by step and uncover the truth behind the statements.

The Mighty Blast Furnace and Haematite

Let's look at the assertion first: "For the extraction of iron, haematite ore is used."
Is this true? Absolutely! When we talk about the commercial extraction of iron, the blast furnace is the undisputed king. And the primary raw material fed into the top of this massive furnace is none other than Haematite.
Haematite is an incredibly rich source of iron. It is mixed with coke (which acts as a reducing agent) and limestone (which acts as a flux to remove impurities). As the mixture descends through the intense heat of the furnace, a series of complex thermodynamic reactions occur, ultimately yielding molten pig iron at the bottom. Because of its abundance and high iron concentration, haematite is the preferred choice for metallurgists worldwide. Therefore, our assertion is a solid, undeniable fact.

Decoding the Ores of Iron

Now, let's shift our focus to the reason provided: "Heamatite is a carbonate ore of iron."
There is a massive catch here. To evaluate this claim, we need to dive into the chemical composition of the common ores of iron. Let's list them out:
1. Haematite: This is an oxide ore, and its chemical formula is
. 2. Magnetite: Another oxide ore, with the formula
. It is highly magnetic. 3. Siderite: This is the carbonate ore of iron, with the formula
. 4. Iron Pyrites: A sulphide ore, famously known as "fool's gold," with the formula
.
Do you see the trap? The reason claims that haematite is a carbonate ore. But as we just established, the carbonate ore of iron is actually Siderite (
). Haematite is an oxide ore (
).

The Final Verdict

So, what exactly is haematite? It is an oxide ore, not a carbonate. This confirms that the reason provided in the question is completely and factually incorrect.
Since the assertion is true but the reason is false, we can confidently select our final answer. Option (d) is the correct choice.
This problem serves as a brilliant reminder of why memorizing the chemical formulas of common ores is so crucial in chemistry. A single word like "carbonate" instead of "oxide" completely flips the truth value of a statement. Always stay sharp, trust your fundamental facts, and don't let these tricky statements catch you off guard!

Similar Questions

JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

Match List-I and List-II. Choose the correct answer from the options given below.

(A)
A 2, B 3, C 1, D 4
(B)
A 4, B 1, C 2, D 3
(C)
A 1, B 3, C 2, D 4
(D)
A 2, B 1, C 4, D 3
JEE Main 2019
LEVELJEE Main

The one that is not a carbonate ore is

(A)
siderite
(B)
calamine
(C)
malachite
(D)
bauxite
JEE Advanced 2015
LEVELJEE Main

Match the anionic species given in Column-I that are present in the ore(s) given in Column-II

List-I

(P)
Carbonate
(Q)
Sulphide
(R)
Hydroxide
(S)
Oxide

List-II

(1)
Siderite
(2)
Malachite
(3)
Bauxite
(4)
Calamine
(5)
Argentite
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

Match List-I with List-II. $\begin{array}{ll} \text{List-I} & \text{List-II} \\ \text{A. Siderite} & \text{(i) Cu} \\ \text{B. Calamine} & \text{(ii) Ca} \\ \text{C. Malachite} & \text{(iii) Fe} \\ \text{D. Cryolite} & \text{(iv) Al} \\ & \text{(v) Zn} \end{array}$ Choose the correct answer from the options given below.

(A)
A (iii), B (i), C (v), D (ii)
(B)
A (i), B (ii), C (v), D (iii)
(C)
A (iii), B (v), C (i), D (iv)
(D)
A (i), B (ii), C (iii), D (iv)
JEE Main 2019
LEVELJEE Main

Match the ores (Column A) with the metals (Column B). \begin{array}{llll} \hline & \text{Column A (Ores)} & & \text{Column B (Metals)} \\ \hline \text{A.} & \text{Siderite} & \text{P.} & \text{Zinc} \\ \text{B.} & \text{Kaolinite} & \text{Q.} & \text{Copper} \\ \text{C.} & \text{Malachite} & \text{R.} & \text{Iron} \\ \text{D.} & \text{Calamine} & \text{S.} & \text{Aluminium} \\ \hline \end{array}

(A)
A - P; B- Q; C - R; D- S
(B)
A - R; B- S; C - P; D- Q
(C)
A - Q; B- R; C - S; D- P
(D)
A - R; B- S; C - Q; D- P
JEE Main 2019
LEVELJEE Main

The ore that contains the metal in the form of fluoride is

(A)
magnetite
(B)
sphalerite
(C)
malachite
(D)
cryolite
JEE Main 2021
LEVELBoard

Match List-I with List-II. Choose the correct answer from the options given below.

(A)
A 4, B 3, C 2, D 1
(B)
A 2, B 4, C 1, D 3
(C)
A 1, B 2, C 3, D 4
(D)
A 3, B 1, C 4, D 2
JEE Main 2021
LEVELBoard

Calamine and malachite, respectively, are the ores of

(A)
nickel and aluminium
(B)
zinc and copper
(C)
copper and iron
(D)
aluminium and zinc
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

Match List-I with List-II. Choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below.

(A)
A-(i), B-(iii), C-(iv), D-(ii)
(B)
A-(ii), B-(i), C-(iv), D-(iii)
(C)
A-(ii), B-(iv), C-(i), D-(iii)
(D)
A-(iii), B-(i), C-(ii), D-(iv)
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

Which of the following ore is concentrated using group 1 cyanide salt ?

(A)
Calamine
(B)
Malachite
(C)
Siderite
(D)
Sphalerite