Animated Solution for Physics - Kinematics: A boat which has a speed of 5 km/h in still water crosses a river of width 1 km along the shortest possible path in 15 min. The velocity of the river water in km/h is
Select Answer:
Visualized Solution
The River Crossing Setup
River width d=1 km.
The boat must cross along the shortest possible path.
Speed of boat in still water vbr=5 km/h.
Time taken to cross t=15 min.
Condition for Shortest Path
The shortest path is a straight line perpendicular to the river banks.
The net velocity vb must point straight across.
To achieve this, the boat must head diagonally upstream to counteract the river flow vr.
The Velocity Vector Triangle
vr: River velocity (pointing downstream).
vbr: Boat velocity in still water (pointing upstream).
Using Pythagoras theorem on the velocity triangle:
vbr2=vb2+vr2
Rearranging for the net velocity vb:
vb=vbr2−vr2
The Time Equation
Time taken is distance divided by the velocity along that path.
t=vbd
Substituting the expression for vb:
t=vbr2−vr2d
Unit Conversion
Distance d=1 km
Speed vbr=5 km/h
Time t=15 min. We must convert this to hours.
t=6015 hr=41 hr
Substituting the Values
Substitute d=1, vbr=5, and t=41 into the time equation.
41=52−vr21
41=25−vr21
Squaring Both Sides
To eliminate the square root, square both sides of the equation.
(41)2=(25−vr21)2
161=25−vr21
Cross Multiplication
Since the numerators are equal, the denominators must be equal.
25−vr2=16
Isolating vr2
Rearrange the equation to solve for vr2.
vr2=25−16
vr2=9
Final Velocity of the River
Take the square root to find the final velocity.
vr=9
vr=3 km/h
The correct option is (b).
00:00 / 00:00
The Sigma Insight: Relative Velocity
Solution Diagram
The River Crossing Conundrum
Imagine you are standing on the bank of a mighty river. The river is exactly 1 km wide. You have a motorboat, and your mission is to cross this river along the shortest possible path. What does that mean geometrically? The shortest distance between two parallel lines (the river banks) is a straight line perpendicular to them.
So, your goal is to travel straight across. Your boat's engine is capable of pushing it at a speed of 5 km/h in perfectly still water. We are also given a crucial piece of information: it takes you exactly 15 min to complete this crossing. The mystery we need to solve is: how fast is the river flowing?
The Trap of the Flowing River
Here is where many students fall into a classic kinematics trap. If you simply point the nose of your boat straight across the river, will you travel along the shortest path? Absolutely not!
As your boat moves forward, the river's current, with velocity vr, will relentlessly sweep you downstream. Your actual path relative to the ground will be a diagonal line, which is significantly longer than the straight width of the river.
To achieve the true shortest path, you must fight the river. You must steer your boat diagonally upstream. By doing this, a component of your boat's velocity cancels out the river's flow, allowing your net movement to be perfectly straight across.
The Velocity Vector Triangle
Let's visualize this struggle using vectors. Your boat's velocity in still water is vbr. The river's velocity is vr. The resultant velocity, which is your actual velocity relative to the ground, is vb.
By the law of vector addition, your actual velocity is the sum of your boat's effort and the river's push:
vb=vbr+vr
Since we demand that vb points straight across the river, it must be exactly perpendicular to the river's flow vr. When we draw these vectors head-to-tail, they form a beautiful right-angled triangle!
The Master Equation
In this right-angled velocity triangle, the hypotenuse is the boat's speed in still water, vbr, because it is the longest vector. The other two perpendicular sides are the river's speed vr and your resultant speed straight across, vb.
We can now summon the Pythagorean theorem:
vbr2=vb2+vr2
We want to find our effective crossing speed, vb. Rearranging the equation gives:
vb=vbr2−vr2
Now, we bridge the gap between geometry and kinematics. The time t taken to cross the river is simply the distance d divided by the velocity along that specific distance, which is vb.
t=vbd=vbr2−vr2d
The Execution and the Silly Mistake Trap
We are armed with our master equation and our given values: d=1 km, vbr=5 km/h, and t=15 min.
Warning: This is where the examiner tests your alertness. Do not mix minutes and hours! We must convert the time into hours to maintain consistent units across the board.
t=6015 hr=41 hr
Now, we substitute these pristine values into our master equation:
41=52−vr21
41=25−vr21
The Final Algebraic Sprint
To liberate our unknown variable vr from the square root, we square both sides of the equation. This is a standard algebraic maneuver to simplify radical expressions.
(41)2=(25−vr21)2
161=25−vr21
Since the numerators on both sides are identical (both are 1), their denominators must be perfectly equal. This gives us a beautifully simple linear equation:
25−vr2=16
Rearranging the terms to isolate vr2:
vr2=25−16=9
Taking the square root of both sides reveals our final answer:
vr=3 km/h
The river is flowing at a steady speed of 3 km/h. The true elegance of this problem lies in how a physical constraint (the shortest path) translates perfectly into a geometric condition (a right-angled vector triangle), which then seamlessly yields a clean algebraic solution.