The Setup
A Tale of Two Wires
Imagine a metallic wire hanging from the ceiling. When we pull it downwards with a constant force F, it stretches slightly, acting much like a very stiff spring. We are given that this initial wire, with length l1 and diameter d1, experiences an elongation of Δl1=0.04 m.
Now, we are presented with a second wire. This new wire is made of the exact same metal, but its dimensions have been scaled up. Its length is doubled (l2=2l1), and its diameter is also doubled (d2=2d1). We apply the exact same force F to this new wire. The question is: how much will it stretch?
The Master Equation
Young's Modulus
To understand how a material responds to stretching, we rely on Young's Modulus (Y). It is defined as the ratio of tensile stress to tensile strain.
Mathematically, this gives us our master equation:
Y=StrainStress=Δl/lF/A=A⋅ΔlF⋅l
Because both wires are made of the same uniform metal, their Young's Modulus is identical (Y1=Y2). This is the crucial physical constraint that allows us to link the two scenarios together.
The Geometry Trap
Area vs. Diameter
Before we equate the two scenarios, we must be very careful with the cross-sectional area. The area of a circular wire is given by A=4πd2.
Notice that the area depends on the square of the diameter. When the diameter is doubled (d2=2d1), the new area becomes:
A2=4π(2d1)2=4(4πd12)=4A1
So, the second wire isn't just twice as thick; it has four times the cross-sectional area! This makes it significantly stiffer.
The Grand Cancellation
Now, let's equate the Young's Modulus for both wires:
A1⋅Δl1F⋅l1=A2⋅Δl2F⋅l2
Substitute the relationships we found (l2=2l1 and A2=4A1):
A1⋅0.04F⋅l1=(4A1)⋅Δl2F⋅(2l1)
This is where the magic happens. The force F, the initial length l1, and the initial area A1 are present on both sides of the equation. They cancel out beautifully, leaving us with a pure numerical relationship:
The Final Stretch
Simplifying the fraction on the right side gives:
Cross-multiplying yields:
The question specifically asks for the answer in centimeters. Multiplying by 100, we get our final answer:
Physical Intuition: Doubling the length of the wire tries to double the elongation (making it 0.08 m). However, doubling the diameter increases the area by a factor of 4, which makes the wire four times harder to stretch. The net effect is 42=21, meaning the final elongation is exactly half of the original!