Animated Solution for Physics - Kinematics: Two vectors P and Q have equal magnitudes. If the magnitude of P+Q is n times the magnitude of P−Q, then angle between P and Q is
Select Answer:
Visualized Solution
Visualizing P and Q
Let the vectors be P and Q.
Angle between them is θ.
Given: ∣P∣=∣Q∣=P.
Magnitudes of Sum and Difference
∣P+Q∣=P2+Q2+2PQcosθ
∣P−Q∣=P2+Q2−2PQcosθ
Applying the Given Condition
Given: ∣P+Q∣=n∣P−Q∣
Squaring Both Sides
P2+Q2+2PQcosθ=nP2+Q2−2PQcosθ
P2+Q2+2PQcosθ=n2(P2+Q2−2PQcosθ)
Substituting P=Q
P2+P2+2P2cosθ=n2(P2+P2−2P2cosθ)
2P2+2P2cosθ=n2(2P2−2P2cosθ)
Factoring and Canceling 2P2
2P2(1+cosθ)=n2⋅2P2(1−cosθ)
1+cosθ=n2(1−cosθ)
Grouping cosθ Terms
1+cosθ=n2−n2cosθ
cosθ+n2cosθ=n2−1
cosθ(1+n2)=n2−1
Final Answer
cosθ=n2+1n2−1
θ=cos−1(n2+1n2−1)
Geometric Insight (If n=1)
If n=1, then cosθ=0⟹θ=90∘.
Diagonals of a rhombus are equal only if it is a square!
00:00 / 00:00
The Sigma Insight: Vector Addition, Subtraction, and Resolution
Solution Diagram
The Geometry of Vector Addition
Imagine you are looking at two vectors, P and Q, originating from the exact same point. The problem tells us a very specific and beautiful constraint: their magnitudes are perfectly equal. Let's call this common magnitude P.
Now, when we add these two vectors, P+Q, we are geometrically finding the main diagonal of the parallelogram formed by them. Conversely, when we subtract them, P−Q, we are finding the length of the other diagonal. The question states that the length of the main diagonal is n times the length of the other diagonal.
The Master Equation
Let's translate this geometric reality into pure algebra. The magnitude of the sum and difference of two vectors separated by an angle θ are given by standard formulas:
∣P+Q∣=P2+Q2+2PQcosθ
∣P−Q∣=P2+Q2−2PQcosθ
According to the problem, ∣P+Q∣=n∣P−Q∣. Substituting our formulas into this condition gives us:
P2+Q2+2PQcosθ=nP2+Q2−2PQcosθ
Simplifying the Algebra
Square roots can be visually intimidating and algebraically clunky. Let's square both sides to shatter them. Don't forget to square the n as well!
P2+Q2+2PQcosθ=n2(P2+Q2−2PQcosθ)
Here is where the magic happens. We know that the magnitudes are equal, so we can substitute Q with P everywhere in the equation.
P2+P2+2P2cosθ=n2(P2+P2−2P2cosθ)
2P2+2P2cosθ=n2(2P2−2P2cosθ)
Notice how every single term now contains a 2P2. We can factor this out on both sides:
2P2(1+cosθ)=n2⋅2P2(1−cosθ)
Since the vectors are non-zero, 2P2 is not zero, and we can safely cancel it out entirely. The equation collapses into something incredibly elegant:
1+cosθ=n2(1−cosθ)
Final Calculation
Our goal is to isolate θ. Let's expand the right side and group all the cosθ terms together.
1+cosθ=n2−n2cosθ
Moving the cosine terms to the left and the constants to the right:
cosθ+n2cosθ=n2−1
cosθ(1+n2)=n2−1
Finally, divide by (1+n2) to isolate cosθ:
cosθ=n2+1n2−1
Taking the inverse cosine gives us our final angle:
θ=cos−1(n2+1n2−1)
A Geometric Thought Experiment: What if n=1? This would mean the diagonals of our parallelogram are perfectly equal. Our formula would give cosθ=0, meaning θ=90∘. A parallelogram with equal adjacent sides (a rhombus) that has equal diagonals is strictly a square. Physics and geometry are always in perfect harmony!