Imagine you are an electrical engineer tasked with designing a heating element. You have two different circuit designs in front of you, and you need them to dissipate the exact same amount of average power. This is the beautiful puzzle we are about to solve!
The magic of AC circuits lies in their dynamic nature. Let's break down the two circuits we have.
Analyzing the Setup
When we look at Circuit A, it's a straightforward, no-nonsense setup. It is a purely resistive circuit containing only a 5Ω resistor connected to a 220 V AC source.
Circuit B, however, is a different beast. It's a series LCR circuit. It contains the same 5Ω resistor, but it also has a 0.1 H inductor and a 40μF capacitor. Both circuits are driven by the same 220 V source.
The Master Equation
To find the condition where both circuits dissipate the same power, we need to write down their power equations. For the purely resistive Circuit A, the average power is simply:
For the LCR Circuit B, the power depends on the impedance Z and the power factor cosϕ. The power factor is the unsung hero of AC power; it tells us how much of the total power is actually doing useful work. The average power is:
Substituting Irms=ZVrms and cosϕ=ZR, we get:
The Resonance Revelation
The problem states a very interesting condition: the average power dissipated in one cycle is the same for both circuits. So, let's equate Pa and Pb:
Notice how beautifully the Vrms2 terms cancel out from both sides. Cross-multiplying, we find that:
This is a massive hint! We know the expression for impedance Z in an LCR circuit is Z2=R2+(XL−XC)2. Substituting this into our equation:
The R2 terms cancel out, leaving us with (XL−XC)2=0, which means:
This is the hallmark of resonance! The inductor and capacitor are engaged in a perfect cosmic dance, effectively canceling each other's reactance out.
Final Calculation
Since the inductive reactance equals the capacitive reactance, we can write ωL=ωC1. Rearranging this gives us the classic formula for resonant angular frequency:
Now, let's bring in the values from our circuit. We substitute L=0.1 H and C=40×10−6 F:
Let's calculate carefully. 0.1×40=4. The square root of 4×10−6 is 2×10−3.
One divided by this value gives us 1000/2, which is exactly:
So, at an angular frequency of 500 rad/s, the LCR circuit hits resonance. It behaves purely resistively, making its power dissipation identical to Circuit A. What an elegant result!