A train with cross-sectional area S_t is moving with speed v_t inside a long tunnel of cross-section

Q: Why do we change the frame of reference to the train?

In the ground frame, the air is mostly stationary, but the train is moving, making the boundaries time-dependent. By shifting to the train's frame, the boundaries (train and tunnel) become stationary, and we have a steady flow of air approaching at $v_t$. This allows us to use standard fluid dynamics equations like Bernoulli's.

Q: Why is the area for the second state $S_0 - S_t$?

The air cannot flow through the train. It must squeeze through the annular space between the train's outer surface and the tunnel's inner wall. The cross-sectional area of this gap is simply the total tunnel area minus the train's area.

Q: Can we ignore the height difference in Bernoulli's equation?

Yes. The problem implies a horizontal tunnel, and the vertical dimensions of the train are small enough that the hydrostatic pressure difference ($\rho g h$) is negligible compared to the dynamic pressure changes ($\frac{1}{2}\rho v^2$) at high speeds.

Q: Why does the pressure drop when the air speeds up?

This is the core of Bernoulli's principle, which is essentially conservation of energy for fluids. If the fluid gains kinetic energy (speeds up), it must lose pressure energy to keep the total energy constant along the streamline.

Q: What does the value of $N$ physically represent?

$N$ is just a mathematical constant in the given expression to test your algebraic derivation. However, the overall expression $\frac{7}{18}\rho v_t^2$ represents the dynamic pressure difference, which is directly responsible for the aerodynamic drag force experienced by the train in the tunnel.

Question

A train with cross-sectional area $S_t$ is moving with speed $v_t$ inside a long tunnel of cross-sectional area $S_0$ ($S_0 = 4S_t$). Assume that almost all the air (density $\rho$) in front of the train flows back between its sides and the walls of the tunnel. Also, the air flow with respect to the train is steady and laminar. Take the ambient pressure and that inside the train to be $p_0$. If the pressure in the region between the sides of the train and the tunnel walls is $p$, then $p_0 - p = \frac{7}{2N} \rho v_t^2$. The value of $N$ is ________.

Sigma Percentile · Accepted Answer

### The Aerodynamics of a Speeding Train: Unlocking Bernoulli's Principle

Have you ever stood on a station platform when a high-speed train blasts past? You likely felt a sudden, powerful force pulling you toward the tracks. This phenomenon isn't magic; it's fluid dynamics in action. In this problem, we explore the exact same physics, but inside the confined space of a tunnel. Let's break down the mechanics of a train moving through a tunnel and discover how speed and pressure are intimately connected.

### Phase 1: The Frame of Reference

When dealing with moving objects and fluids, choosing the right perspective is half the battle. If we stand on the ground, the air is mostly still, and the train is moving. This makes the boundaries of our system constantly change, which is a nightmare for calculations.

Instead, let's hop onto the train! By shifting our **frame of reference** to the moving train, the train becomes stationary. From this viewpoint, it is the air inside the tunnel that is rushing toward us with a speed of $v_t$. This simple mental shift transforms a complex, time-dependent problem into a steady-state flow problem, allowing us to use our standard fluid dynamics toolkit.

### Phase 2: The Squeeze (Equation of Continuity)

As the air approaches the train, it encounters an obstacle. It can't flow *through* the train, so it must squeeze through the narrow gap between the train's outer surface and the tunnel's inner walls.

To understand what happens to the air's speed, we use the **Principle of Continuity**, which states that for an incompressible fluid, the volume flow rate must remain constant. Mathematically, $A_1 v_1 = A_2 v_2$.

Far ahead of the train, the air flows through the entire cross-sectional area of the tunnel, $S_0$, at speed $v_t$. When it reaches the train, the available area is reduced to the tunnel area minus the train's area, which is $S_0 - S_t$. Let's call the new speed $v$.

$$S_0 v_t = (S_0 - S_t) v$$

We are given that the tunnel is four times the size of the train, so $S_0 = 4S_t$. Substituting this in:

$$4S_t v_t = (4S_t - S_t) v$$

$$4S_t v_t = 3S_t v$$

$$v = \frac{4}{3}v_t$$

Because the area decreased, the air had to speed up to maintain the flow rate. The air in the gap is moving $33\%$ faster than the air ahead of the train!

### Phase 3: The Pressure Drop (Bernoulli's Equation)

Now that we know the speeds, we can find the pressure. This is where **Bernoulli's Equation** shines. It tells us that along a horizontal streamline, the sum of pressure energy and kinetic energy per unit volume is constant.

$$p_1 + \frac{1}{2}\rho v_1^2 = p_2 + \frac{1}{2}\rho v_2^2$$

Let's apply this from a point far ahead of the train (where pressure is $p_0$ and speed is $v_t$) to a point in the narrow gap (where pressure is $p$ and speed is $v$).

$$p_0 + \frac{1}{2}\rho v_t^2 = p + \frac{1}{2}\rho v^2$$

We want to find the pressure drop, $p_0 - p$. Rearranging the equation:

$$p_0 - p = \frac{1}{2}\rho (v^2 - v_t^2)$$

Now, we substitute the speed $v = \frac{4}{3}v_t$ that we found earlier:

$$p_0 - p = \frac{1}{2}\rho \left(\left(\frac{4}{3}v_t\right)^2 - v_t^2\right)$$

$$p_0 - p = \frac{1}{2}\rho \left(\frac{16}{9}v_t^2 - v_t^2\right)$$

$$p_0 - p = \frac{1}{2}\rho \left(\frac{7}{9}v_t^2\right)$$

$$p_0 - p = \frac{7}{18}\rho v_t^2$$

### Final Calculation

The problem states that the pressure drop is given by the expression $\frac{7}{2N}\rho v_t^2$. By comparing our derived result with the given expression, we can easily find the unknown integer $N$.

$$\frac{7}{18}\rho v_t^2 = \frac{7}{2N}\rho v_t^2$$

Equating the denominators:

$$2N = 18$$

$$N = 9$$

This elegant result highlights a profound physical truth: whenever a fluid is forced through a restriction, its speed increases, and its pressure drops. This pressure difference creates a suction force, which is exactly why you must stand behind the yellow line on a train platform!

Enter Numerical Value:

Visualized Solution

Frame of Reference

Equation of Continuity

Substituting Areas

Calculating $v$

Bernoulli's Equation

Pressure Difference

Evaluating $p_{0} - p$

Finding $N$

Physical Insight

The Sigma Insight: Flow of Fluid

The Aerodynamics of a Speeding Train

Phase 1

Phase 2

Phase 3

Final Calculation

Similar Questions

Water flows in a horizontal tube (see figure). The pressure of water changes by $700 Nm^{- 2}$ between $A$ and $B$ , where the area of cross-section are $40 cm^{2}$ and $20 cm^{2}$ , respectively. Find the rate of flow of water through the tube. (Take, density of water = $1000 kgm^{- 3}$ )

A liquid of density $ρ$ is coming out of a hose pipe of radius $a$ with horizontal speed $v$ and hits a mesh. 50\% of the liquid passes through the mesh unaffected 25\% losses all of its momentum and, 25\% comes back with the same speed. The resultant pressure on the mesh will be

Water from a tap emerges vertically downwards with an initial speed of $1.0 m/s$ . The cross-sectional area of tap is $1 0^{- 4} m^{2}$ . Assume that the pressure is constant throughout the stream of water and that the flow is steady, the cross-sectional area of stream $0.15 m$ below the tap is

An ideal fluid flows (laminar flow) through a pipe of non-uniform diameter. The maximum and minimum diameters of the pipes are $6.4 cm$ and $4.8 cm$ , respectively. The ratio of the minimum and the maximum velocities of fluid in this pipe is

A cylinder of height $20 m$ is completely filled with water. The velocity of efflux of water (in $ms^{- 1}$ ) through a small hole on the side wall of the cylinder near its bottom, is