Sigma Percentile
JEE Main 2023 (24 January Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Animated Solution for Mathematics - Sets and Relations: The relation is:

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

Understanding the Relation

  • The relation is defined on integers as:
  • Condition 1: (The numbers must be co-prime).
  • Condition 2: (Twice the first number cannot equal the second).

Testing for Reflexivity

  • For to be reflexive, every integer must relate to itself: .
  • This means both conditions must hold for :
  • 1.
  • 2.

Reflexivity Counter-example

  • Let's test with a simple integer, say .
  • Check Condition 1: .
  • Since , the first condition fails immediately.
  • Therefore, , meaning is not reflexive.

Testing for Symmetry

  • For to be symmetric, if , then .
  • Let's pick and .
  • Check : (True) and (True).
  • So, the pair is in our relation .

Symmetry Failure

  • Now, we must check the reverse pair: .
  • Condition 1: (True).
  • Condition 2: We need . Here, , which exactly equals .
  • This violates the second condition! So, .
  • Conclusion: is not symmetric.

Testing for Transitivity (Part 1)

  • For to be transitive, if and , then .
  • Let's choose , , and .
  • Check : and . So, .

Testing for Transitivity (Part 2)

  • Now check the second pair .
  • Condition 1: (True, they are co-prime).
  • Condition 2: (True).
  • So, .

Transitivity Failure

  • Finally, we check if the first and last elements relate: .
  • Condition 1 requires .
  • But , which is not equal to .
  • Since this fails, .
  • Conclusion: is not transitive.

Final Conclusion

  • We have systematically tested all three properties.
  • The relation is:
  • - Not Reflexive
  • - Not Symmetric
  • - Not Transitive
  • Final Answer: neither symmetric nor transitive.

The Sigma Insight: Types of Relations

Analyzing the Setup

Welcome, fellow traveler, to the fascinating world of relations! Today, we are not just solving a problem; we are dissecting the very fabric of mathematical logic.
We are given a relation defined on the set of integers , and our mission is to determine its properties: reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity. The relation is defined as:
Think of this as a club with two strict bouncers at the door. The first bouncer, , demands that you and your partner be co-prime. The second bouncer, $2a eq b$, demands that your partner cannot be exactly twice your value. To be in the club, you must pass both!

The Mirror Test

Reflexivity
Imagine standing in front of a mirror. A relation is reflexive if every element sees itself in the mirror and is accepted into the club.
Mathematically, this means for every , the pair must be in . Let's test this. If we plug into our bouncers, the first one asks: Is ?
For any integer , the is simply . So, if we pick , the . The bouncer shakes his head—$2 eq 1$.
The condition fails immediately. Because we found at least one integer that fails the test, we can confidently declare that the relation is not reflexive.

The Dance of Symmetry

Now, let's talk about symmetry. A relation is symmetric if, whenever you are related to your friend, your friend is also related to you.
If , then must also be in . Let's test this with a pair that actually makes it into the club. Let and .
First, (Pass). Second, $2(2) = 4 eq 1$ (Pass). So, .
Now, let's check the reverse: . The first bouncer says (Pass). But the second bouncer, $2a eq b$, looks at .
Since , the condition $2a eq b$ is violated! The pair is rejected. Because the reverse trip is not allowed, the relation is not symmetric.

The Chain Reaction

Transitivity
Finally, we arrive at transitivity, the ultimate test of connection. Transitivity asks: If is related to , and is related to , does have to be related to ?
Let's build a chain. Let . First, check : and $2(2) = 4 eq 3$. It's in!
Now, check : and $2(3) = 6 eq 4$. It's in too! Now, for the final link: .
The first bouncer checks . Wait, . The bouncer stops us—$2 eq 1$. The pair is not in the relation. The chain is broken. Thus, the relation is not transitive.

The Final Verdict

We have walked through the landscape of this relation, testing its boundaries and finding its limits. We discovered it is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.
It is a beautiful example of how simple rules can create complex, non-trivial structures. Keep exploring, keep questioning, and remember: in mathematics, a single counter-example is all it takes to change the entire story. You have mastered this logic today!

Similar Questions

JEE Main 2023 (31 January Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Let be a relation on defined by if and only if . Then is

(A)
symmetric but neither reflexive nor transitive
(B)
transitive but neither reflexive nor symmetric
(C)
reflexive and symmetric but not transitive
(D)
symmetric and transitive but not reflexive
JEE Main 2004
LEVELBoard

Let be a relation on the set . The relation R is

(A)
reflexive
(B)
transitive
(C)
not symmetric
(D)
a function
JEE Main 2018 (15 April Shift 1)
LEVELBoard

Consider the following two binary relations on the set A={a,b,c}: and . Then

(A)
is not symmetric but it is transitive.
(B)
both and are transitive
(C)
is symmetric but it is not transitive
(D)
both and are not symmetric
JEE Main 2005
LEVELBoard

Let be a relation on the set . The relation is

(A)
reflexive and transitive only
(B)
reflexive only
(C)
an equivalence relation
(D)
reflexive and symmetric only
JEE Main 2024 (04 Apr Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Main

Let a relation on be defined as: if and only if or . Consider the two statements: (I) is reflexive but not symmetric. (II) is transitive Then which one of the following is true?

(A)
(1) Both (I) and (II) are correct.
(B)
(2) Only (II) is correct.
(C)
(3) Neither (I) nor (II) is correct.
(D)
(4) Only (I) is correct.
JEE Main 2024 (08 Apr Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Main

Let and . Let be a relation on defined by if and only if is an even integer. Then the relation is

(A)
(1) an equivalence relation.
(B)
(2) reflexive and symmetric but not transitive.
(C)
(3) transitive but not symmetric.
(D)
(4) reflexive but not symmetric.
JEE Main 2023 (08 Apr Shift 2)
LEVELBoard

Let . Then the relation is

(A)
an equivalence relation
(B)
symmetric but neither reflexive nor transitive
(C)
transitive but neither symmetric nor reflexive
(D)
reflexive but neither symmetric nor transitive
JEE Main 2021 (31 Aug Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Which of the following is *not* correct for relation on the set of real numbers?

(A)
is neither transitive nor symmetric.
(B)
is symmetric and transitive.
(C)
is reflexive but not symmetric.
(D)
is reflexive and symmetric.
JEE Main 2023 (01 February Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Let be a relation on , given by . Then is

(A)
Reflexive but neither symmetric nor transitive
(B)
Reflexive and transitive but not symmetric
(C)
Reflexive and symmetric but not transitive
(D)
An equivalence relation
JEE Main 2025 April
LEVELJEE Main

Let be the set of all functions and be a relation on such that . Then is:

(A)
Symmetric and transitive but not reflective
(B)
Symmetric but neither reflective nor transitive
(C)
Reflexive but neither symmetric nor transitive
(D)
Transitive but neither reflexive nor symmetric