Sigma Percentile
JEE Main 2013
LEVELJEE Advanced

Animated Solution for Chemistry - Coordination Compounds: The equation which is balanced and represents the correct product(s) is

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

Analyzing Reaction Feasibility

  • Evaluate the four given chemical equations for thermodynamic and stoichiometric correctness.

The Analytical Tools

  • 1. Acid-Base Strength
  • 2. Charge Conservation
  • 3. Redox Properties of Ligands

Evaluating Option (a)

  • Basicity order:
  • A weaker base cannot generate a stronger base.

Evaluating Option (c)

  • Charge of
  • Charge of
  • Net charge
  • Product should be

Evaluating Option (d)

  • is a strong reducing agent.
  • It reduces to and forms cyanogen gas .
  • A complex is not formed.

Evaluating Option (b)

  • In acidic medium, acts as a base and gets protonated:
  • The complex decomposes, releasing and .

Final Conclusion

  • Option (b) is chemically feasible and stoichiometrically balanced.

The Way Forward

  • What if we reacted with instead of ?
  • Would a redox reaction still occur?

The Sigma Insight: Nomenclature, Isomerism, Importance and Werner's Theory

Solution Diagram

The Setup

A Test of Chemical Intuition
Imagine you are a chemical detective presented with four suspect equations. Your job is to find the one that is chemically feasible and stoichiometrically balanced.
This isn't just about counting atoms; it's about understanding the underlying chemical principles. We need to evaluate acid-base strength, charge conservation, and redox behavior.
Let's put these equations under the microscope.

Option A

The Battle of Bases
Our first suspect is the reaction between lithium oxide and potassium chloride.
At first glance, it looks like a simple double displacement. But we must consider the acid-base strength of the oxides.
As we move down the alkali metal group, the metal-oxygen bond becomes more ionic, making the oxide a stronger base. Therefore, potassium oxide is a much stronger base than lithium oxide.
A fundamental rule of chemistry is that a weaker base cannot spontaneously generate a stronger base. Thus, this reaction is a chemical dead end.

Option C

The Charge Trap
Next, we examine the reaction of the magnesium aqua complex with EDTA.
The reaction itself is a classic ligand substitution, but look closely at the product's charge.
Magnesium is in the oxidation state, and the fully deprotonated EDTA ligand carries a charge.
By simple charge conservation, the net charge of the resulting complex must be the sum of these charges: .
The equation incorrectly shows a charge for the product. The correct product is . This option is a classic trap!

Option D

The Hidden Redox Reaction
Now, let's look at the interaction between copper sulphate and potassium cyanide.
You might expect cyanide to simply replace the sulphate and water ligands to form a tetracyanocuprate(II) complex. However, cyanide is a pseudohalide and a strong reducing agent.
When it encounters the oxidizing Cu(II) ion, a redox reaction takes precedence over simple complexation. Cyanide reduces Cu(II) to Cu(I), forming insoluble copper(I) cyanide and releasing cyanogen gas.
Because of this hidden redox behavior, a stable Cu(II) cyanide complex is not formed. This equation is chemically flawed.

Option B

The Acidic Demise of Ammine Complexes
Finally, we arrive at the cobalt ammine complex in an acidic medium.
Ammonia is a Lewis base. When an ammine complex is placed in a strongly acidic environment, the abundant hydrogen ions attack the ammonia ligands.
The ammonia is protonated to form the ammonium ion (). Because the ammonium ion lacks a lone pair, it can no longer act as a ligand, causing the coordination sphere to collapse.
The complex decomposes, releasing the central cobalt(II) ion and the chloride ion. This equation perfectly captures this chemical reality and is stoichiometrically balanced.

The Final Verdict

After rigorously testing each equation against the laws of chemistry, only one stands strong.
The decomposition of the ammine complex in acid is the only chemically feasible and balanced reaction.
Option (b) is the correct answer.

Similar Questions

JEE Main 2017
LEVELJEE Main

On treatment of of solution of with excess of ; ions are precipitated. The complex is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

The potassium ferrocyanide solution gives a prussian blue colour, when added to

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
LEVELJEE Main

One mole of the complex compound , gives 3 moles of ions on dissolution in water. One mole of the same complex reacts with two moles of solution to yield two moles of . The structure of the complex is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2018
LEVELJEE Main

The oxidation states of Cr, in , , and respectively are

(A)
, and
(B)
, and
(C)
, and
(D)
, and
JEE Main 2020
LEVELJEE Main

Complex (A) has a composition of . If the complex on treatment with conc. loses of its original mass, the correct molecular formula of (A) is [Given : atomic mass of and ]

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Advanced 2015
LEVELJEE Main

Among the complex ions, , , , , and , the number of complex ion(s) that show(s) cis-trans isomerism is -

JEE Main 2020
LEVELJEE Main

The one that is not expected to show isomerism is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

The correct structures of trans-[NiBr_2(PPh_3)_2] and meridonial-[Co(NH_3)_3(NO_2)_3], respectively are

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

Acidic ferric chloride solution on treatment with excess of potassium ferrocyanide gives a prussian blue coloured colloidal species. It is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2018
LEVELJEE Advanced

Consider the following reaction and statements : I. Two isomers are produces if the reactant complex ion is a cis-isomer. II. Two isomers are produced if the reactant complex ion is a trans-isomer. III. Only one isomer is produced if the reactant complex ion is a trans-isomer. IV. Only one isomer is produced if the reactant complex ion is a cis-isomer. The correct statements are

(A)
(I) and (II)
(B)
(I) and (III)
(C)
(III) and (IV)
(D)
(II) and (IV)