Sigma Percentile
JEE Advanced 1978
LEVELJEE Main

Animated Solution for Mathematics - Basic Mathematics: Show that the square of is a rational number.

Visualized Solution

Let us Define the Expression

  • Let the given expression be
  • Our goal is to show that is a rational number.
  • To do this, we must simplify the nested radicals in both the numerator and the denominator.

Simplifying the Numerator:

  • Focus on the numerator radical:
  • To express the term inside as a perfect square, we need a factor of for the term.
  • Multiply and divide by inside the square root:

Finding the Perfect Square for the Numerator

  • We want to express in the form
  • Let
  • Check the sum of squares:
  • Therefore,

Simplifying the Numerator to its Final Form

  • Substitute the perfect square back:
  • Since , the term is positive.
  • Thus, the simplified numerator is

Simplifying the Denominator Radical:

  • Now focus on the nested radical in the denominator:
  • Again, we need a factor of for the term.
  • Multiply and divide by inside the root:

Finding the Perfect Square for the Denominator

  • We want to express in the form
  • Let
  • Check the sum of squares:
  • Therefore,

Simplifying the Denominator Radical to its Final Form

  • Substitute the perfect square back:
  • Since is clearly positive, we can simplify directly.
  • Thus, the simplified radical is

Substituting Simplified Terms Back into

  • Recall the original expression:
  • Substitute the simplified terms:

Simplifying the Main Fraction

  • Multiply numerator and denominator by to clear the denominators:
  • Simplify the denominator:
  • Resulting expression:

Squaring the Simplified Expression

  • We need to find
  • Expand the numerator:
  • Expand the denominator:

Proving the Result is Rational

  • We have
  • Notice that and .
  • Factor out from the denominator:
  • Cancel the common term:
  • Since is a ratio of two integers, it is a rational number!

The Sigma Insight: Theory of Indices

Solution Diagram

Analyzing the Setup

Welcome, future engineer. Today, we stand before a problem that, at first glance, looks like a tangled mess of roots and irrational numbers. You see the expression:
Your instinct might be to panic, but in the world of JEE Advanced, complexity is often just a mask for hidden simplicity. Our goal is to prove that the square of this expression is a rational number.

Phase 1

The Numerator and the Golden Trick
Let us isolate the numerator: . The problem here is that does not have an even coefficient.
To use the identity , we desperately need that . We perform the 'Golden Trick' of nested radicals by multiplying and dividing by :
Now, look at the numerator . We need to find and such that .
If we set and , let us check the sum of their squares: . It is a perfect match! Thus, the numerator simplifies to:

Phase 2

The Denominator and the Pattern
Now, we turn to the denominator's nested radical: . We apply the same logic, multiplying and dividing by to obtain:
We need , so . Let us test and .
The sum of squares is . Again, it fits perfectly! The denominator radical becomes:

Phase 3

The Assembly
Now, we substitute these simplified forms back into our original expression :
We can clear the double-decker fraction by multiplying the numerator and denominator by :
Simplifying the denominator, we get , which is . So, our expression is:

Phase 4

The Grand Finale
The final step is to square . We have:
Expanding the numerator gives . Expanding the denominator gives .
Now, look closely at the denominator: . If we factor out a , we get .
The numerator and the denominator share the exact same irrational term! They cancel out, leaving us with:
We have arrived. The result is a rational number. This problem teaches us that no matter how intimidating the expression, if you follow the logical structure of algebra, the chaos will always resolve into order.

Similar Questions

JEE Advanced 1980
LEVELBoard

The expression is equal to

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Advanced 1980
LEVELJEE Main

Given for a fixed positive integer , prove that .

JEE Advanced 1985
LEVELJEE Main

Use method of mathematical induction is divisible by 24 for all

JEE Advanced 1978
LEVELBoard

Solve for

JEE Advanced 1979
LEVELBoard

If , find .

JEE Main 2024 (29 Jan Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Main

Let the set . Then is equal to

JEE Main 2020 - 4 Sep (Morning)
LEVELBoard

Given the following two statements: is a tautology : is a fallacy. Then :

(A)
only is correct.
(B)
both and are correct.
(C)
only is correct.
(D)
both and are not correct.
JEE Main 2020 - 6 Sep (Evening)
LEVELBoard

Consider the statement: "For an integer n, if is even, then n is odd." The contrapositive statement of this statement is :

(A)
For an integer n, if n is odd, then is even
(B)
For an integer n, if n is even, then is even.
(C)
For an integer n, if n is even, then is odd.
(D)
For an integer n, if is not even, then n is not odd.
JEE Main 2022 (24 June Shift 2)
LEVELBoard

Consider the following statements : \\ : Rishi is a judge. \\ : Rishi is honest. \\ : Rishi is not arrogant. \\ The negation of the statement "if Rishi is a judge and he is not arrogant, then he is honest" is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2020 - 7 Jan (Morning)
LEVELBoard

The logical statement is equivalent to

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)