Sigma Percentile
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

Animated Solution for Chemistry - Organic Chemistry: Product A is

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

  • The reaction involves an alkene reacting with .
  • This is a classic electrophilic addition reaction where the bond acts as a nucleophile.

  • According to Markownikoff's rule, the electrophile () adds to the carbon with more hydrogen atoms.
  • This ensures the formation of the most stable intermediate carbocation.

  • Protonation of the terminal group leaves a positive charge on the adjacent carbon.
  • This results in a secondary () carbocation.

  • The carbocation is adjacent to a tertiary () carbon.
  • Carbocations will rearrange if a more stable intermediate can be formed.

  • A -hydride shift occurs, moving the hydrogen atom with its electron pair to the positively charged carbon.
  • This forms a highly stable tertiary () carbocation.
  • (Note: Some textbooks mistakenly refer to this as a methyl shift, but a methyl shift here would not increase stability).

  • The nucleophile () attacks the stable carbocation.
  • This yields the major rearranged product.

  • If peroxides were present, the reaction would follow a free-radical mechanism.
  • This would yield the anti-Markownikoff product without any carbocation rearrangement.

The Sigma Insight: Haloalkanes & Haloarenes

Solution Diagram

The Thrill of Electrophilic Addition

When an alkene meets a strong acid like , a fascinating chemical dance begins. This is a classic electrophilic addition reaction, a staple of organic chemistry. The bond of the alkene is electron-rich and acts as a nucleophile, eagerly reaching out to grab the acidic proton () from .
According to Markownikoff's Rule, the proton will attach itself to the carbon atom of the double bond that already has more hydrogen atoms. Why? Because this specific regiochemistry ensures the formation of the most stable possible intermediate carbocation. In our specific molecule, the proton attaches to the terminal group, leaving a positive charge on the adjacent carbon. This gives us a secondary () carbocation.

The Carbocation Crossroads

Spotting the Trap
Now, here is where many students fall into a trap. It is incredibly tempting to immediately attach the waiting bromide ion () to this secondary carbocation and call it a day. However, carbocations are notoriously unstable and will always look for a way to rearrange themselves into a lower-energy state if the molecular geometry allows it.
Look closely at the carbon adjacent to our carbocation. It is a tertiary () carbon attached to the cyclohexane ring, and crucially, it possesses a hydrogen atom.
(A quick note on textbook errors: Some reference materials might mistakenly refer to the next step as a 'methyl shift'. However, if a methyl group were to shift, the positive charge would simply move to another secondary carbon, offering no gain in stability. The true driving force here is the formation of a tertiary carbocation.)

The 1,2-Hydride Shift

To achieve greater stability, a -hydride shift occurs. The hydrogen atom on the tertiary carbon takes its bonding electrons and migrates over to the positively charged secondary carbon.
This elegant internal rearrangement shifts the positive charge onto the tertiary carbon, creating a highly stable carbocation. This new intermediate is significantly lower in energy due to increased hyperconjugation and the inductive effects of the surrounding alkyl groups.

The Final Strike

With the most stable carbocation now formed, the reaction can proceed to its conclusion. The bromide ion (), acting as a nucleophile, attacks the carbocation.
This final step yields our major product: a cyclohexane ring with both a methyl group and a bromine atom attached to the same tertiary carbon, perfectly matching option (d). Always remember, in electrophilic addition reactions, never rush to the final product without first checking for the possibility of a carbocation rearrangement!

Similar Questions