Sigma Percentile
JEE Advanced 1986
LEVELJEE Advanced

Animated Solution for Mathematics - Limits, Continuity and Differentiability: Let denote the greatest integer less than or equal to . If , then is

Select Answer:

* Multiple Correct

Visualized Solution

Visualizing the Inner Function

  • We are given the function , where represents the greatest integer function.
  • Let's define the inner function as .
  • The behavior of is completely determined by the values of .

Understanding the Greatest Integer Function

  • The greatest integer function outputs the largest integer less than or equal to .
  • For example, if , then .
  • If , then .
  • Therefore, we need to find the range of for .

Analyzing the Interval

  • Let's look at the interval where is positive, i.e., .
  • In this region, .
  • Also, the angle lies in , which means .
  • Since both terms are positive, their product must be strictly positive: .

Analyzing the Interval

  • Now let's look at the negative interval, .
  • Here, .
  • The angle lies in , which means .
  • Since both and are negative, their product is positive: .

Finding the Upper Bound of

  • We know for all non-zero , and .
  • Since and , the product must be strictly less than .
  • In fact, the maximum value occurs near , where .
  • Thus, for all , we have the inequality: .

Applying the Greatest Integer Function

  • Since for all , we can apply the greatest integer function.
  • For any value in this range, .
  • Therefore, for all .

Continuity and Differentiability in

  • Since is a constant function on the open interval :
  • 1. It is continuous at .
  • 2. It is continuous in the interval .
  • 3. It is differentiable in the interval with derivative .

Checking Behavior at

  • Let's check if the function is continuous or differentiable at the boundary .
  • At , we have .
  • For (where is a small positive number):
  • .
  • Since is slightly negative, its greatest integer value is .

Discontinuity at

  • The right-hand limit as is .
  • However, the left-hand limit as is , and the function value is .
  • Since the left-hand and right-hand limits are not equal, is discontinuous at .
  • Consequently, is not differentiable at .

Matching the Options

  • Let's review our findings against the given options:
  • 1. Continuous at : True, since in .
  • 2. Continuous in : True, as it is constant there.
  • 3. Differentiable at : False, because it is discontinuous at .
  • 4. Differentiable in : True, since it is a constant function in this interval.
  • Thus, the correct options are (A), (B), and (D).

The Sigma Insight: Relationship Between Continuity and Differentiability

Solution Diagram

The Beauty of the Step

Deconstructing the Greatest Integer Function
Welcome, future engineer. Today, we are going to peel back the layers of a function that often intimidates students: .
When you see the greatest integer brackets, your instinct might be to panic or reach for complex derivatives. But I want you to take a deep breath. In JEE Advanced, the greatest integer function is rarely about calculus; it is almost always about understanding the range of the inner expression.

Phase 1

The Inner Beast
We define our inner function as . This is the heart of our problem.
The behavior of is entirely dictated by the values takes. If we can show that stays trapped within a specific interval, the greatest integer function will collapse into a simple constant.
Imagine as a particle moving on a track. We need to know where it lives.

Phase 2

The Sign Analysis
Let us look at the interval . We must be careful here, as many students assume that because sine is negative in the negative domain, the whole function must be negative.
For , is positive and is positive (since ). Thus, .
Now, consider . Here, is negative. The angle is in , which means is also negative.
A negative multiplied by a negative is a positive! So, here as well. We have discovered that for all except at , our function is strictly positive. At , . Thus, for all .

Phase 3

The Trap of the Interval
Now, how large does get? We know and .
Therefore, the product must be strictly less than . The maximum value occurs near , where:
Since , the function never reaches the integer . We have successfully bounded our function: for all .
This is the 'Aha!' moment. If the input to the greatest integer function is always between and , then the output must be .

Phase 4

The Flattening
Because , we can conclude that for the entire interval , .
The complex trigonometric expression has vanished, replaced by the elegant simplicity of a constant function. A constant function is the most well-behaved creature in calculus.
It is continuous everywhere, and its derivative is zero everywhere. This immediately confirms that is continuous at , continuous in , and differentiable in .

Phase 5

The Cliff at
Finally, we must check the boundary. What happens at ?
We know . But what happens if we step just a tiny bit to the right, to ?
The term becomes , which is negative. Thus, becomes slightly negative. The greatest integer of a slightly negative number is .
We have a jump! The limit from the left is , but the limit from the right is . The function is discontinuous at , and therefore, it cannot be differentiable there.

Similar Questions

JEE Advanced 1986
LEVELJEE Main

The function is

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
continuous nowhere
(B)
continuous everywhere
(C)
differentiable nowhere
(D)
not differentiable at
(E)
not differentiable at infinite number of points
JEE Advanced 1992
LEVELJEE Main

In this questions there are entries in columns I and II. Each entry in column I is related to exactly one entry in column II. Write the correct letter from column II against the entry number in column I in your answer book.

List-I

(P)
(Q)

List-II

(1)
differentiable everywhere
(2)
nowhere differentiable
(3)
not differentiable at 1 and -1
JEE Main 2023 (24 January Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Let ; Then at

(A)
f is continuous but not differentiable
(B)
f is continuous but f' is not continuous
(C)
f and f' both are continuous
(D)
f' is continuous but not differentiable
JEE Advanced 2011
LEVELJEE Main

If

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
is continuous at
(B)
is not differentiable at
(C)
is differentiable at
(D)
is differentiable at
JEE Advanced 1994
LEVELJEE Main

Let , where . At

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
is differentiable but is not continuous
(B)
is differentiable while is not
(C)
both and are differentiable
(D)
is differentiable and is continuous
JEE Main 2021 (27 July Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Main

Let be a function defined by Then which of the following is true ?

(A)
is continuous everywhere but not differentiable exactly at one point in
(B)
is differentiable everywhere in
(C)
is not continuous exactly at two points in
(D)
is continuous everywhere but not differentiable exactly at two points in
JEE Main 2022 (24 June Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Advanced

Let where denotes greatest integer . If is the number of points where is not continuous and is the number of points where is not differentiable, then the ordered pair is :

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2020 - 4 Sep (Evening)
LEVELJEE Main

The function is:

(A)
both continuous and differentiable on
(B)
both continuous and differentiable on
(C)
continuous on and differentiable on
(D)
continuous on and differentiable on
JEE Advanced 1981
LEVELJEE Main

Let be a real-valued function. Then the set of points where is not differentiable is .........

JEE Advanced 2014
LEVELJEE Main

Let be a continuous function and let be defined as then

* Multiple Correct Options
(A)
is continuous but not differentiable at
(B)
is differentiable on
(C)
is continuous but not differentiable at
(D)
is continuous and differentiable at either (a) or (b) but not both