Sigma Percentile
JEE Main 2010
LEVELBoard

Animated Solution for Mathematics - Sets and Relations: Let S be a non-empty subset of R. Consider the following statement : P : There is a rational number such that . Which of the following statements is the negation of the statement P ?

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

Understanding Statement

  • Statement : There is a rational number such that .
  • We need to find the negation of this statement.
  • Let's visualize the real number line and a subset .

Breaking Down the Components

  • The statement has three main parts:
  • Quantifier: "There is" (Existential)
  • Domain: "a rational number "
  • Condition: ""

Symbolic Representation of

  • Let's write using mathematical logic symbols.
  • "There is"
  • "rational number "
  • such that

The Rule of Negation

  • We need to find .
  • Rule for negating quantifiers:
  • The negation of "There exists" () is "For all" ().

Applying Negation to the Quantifier

  • Applying the rule to our statement:

Negating the Condition

  • Now we must negate the inequality condition: .
  • On the real number line, if a number is NOT strictly greater than zero, what is it?
  • It must be less than OR equal to zero.

The Final Symbolic Negation

  • Substituting the negated condition back:
  • This is the complete logical negation of the original statement.

Translating Back to English

  • "" translates to "Every" or "For all".
  • "" translates to "rational number ".
  • "" translates to "satisfies ".
  • Final Sentence: Every rational number satisfies .

Conclusion

  • Comparing with the given options:
  • Option 1: There is no rational number... (Incorrect)
  • Option 2: Every rational number satisfies . (Correct)
  • Option 3: Implication statement... (Incorrect)
  • Option 4: There is a rational number... (Incorrect)
  • Correct Answer: Option 2

The Sigma Insight: Representation of Sets

Solution Diagram

Analyzing the Logical Statement

The statement provided is .
This statement asserts that within the intersection of set and the set of rational numbers , there exists at least one element that is strictly positive. Our objective is to determine the negation, denoted as $ eg P$.

The Quantifier Transformation

The first step in our journey is to understand the power of the quantifier. The symbol stands for "there exists."
When we negate an existential statement, we are essentially asserting that the existence of such an element is impossible. If it is impossible for "at least one" to exist, then it must be true that for all elements, the condition fails.
Thus, the existential quantifier transforms into the universal quantifier . This is the first, and perhaps most critical, shift in our logical perspective.

Negating the Condition

Now, we turn our attention to the condition . If we are negating the claim that is strictly greater than zero, we must consider the entire real number line.
If a number is not strictly greater than zero, it must be either negative or exactly zero. Therefore, the negation of is .

The Final Logical Conclusion

By combining these two insights—the transformation of the quantifier and the negation of the condition—we arrive at our final logical destination:
This translates to: "Every rational number satisfies ."
This is the beauty of logic—it is not about guessing; it is about the systematic, step-by-step dismantling of a statement until only the truth remains. Keep this precision in your toolkit, and you will find that even the most complex problems become clear.

Similar Questions

JEE Main 2020 (7 January Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Main

Let A, B, C and D be four non-empty sets. The Contrapositive statement of “If and then ” is :

(A)
If , then or
(B)
If , then and
(C)
If , then and
(D)
If , then or
JEE Main 2011
LEVELBoard

Consider the following statements P: Suman is brilliant Q: Suman is rich R : Suman is honest The negation of the statement "Suman is brilliant and dishonest if and only if Suman is rich" can be expressed as

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2025 (January)
LEVELJEE Main

Let and . Then is equal to :

(A)
36
(B)
31
(C)
37
(D)
29