Sigma Percentile
JEE Advanced 1997
LEVELJEE Main

Animated Solution for Mathematics - Limits, Continuity and Differentiability: Let be a continuous function defined for . If takes rational values for all and , then

Enter Numerical Value:

Visualized Solution

Visualizing the Domain and Given Point

  • We are given a function defined on the closed interval .
  • The function is continuous on this entire interval.
  • We are also given a specific value: .

The Rational Constraint:

  • The problem states that takes rational values for all .
  • This means the range of is a subset of the rational numbers .
  • No output of the function can be an irrational number like or .

The Intermediate Value Theorem (IVT)

  • If a function is continuous on , it must take every value between and .
  • Mathematically, the image of an interval under a continuous map must be a connected set (an interval).

What if is Not Constant?

  • Suppose is not a constant function.
  • Then, there must exist some and in such that .
  • Let these distinct rational values be and .

Applying IVT to the Non-Constant Path

  • By IVT, since is continuous, it must take all real values between and .
  • Therefore, the range of must contain the entire interval .

The Density of Irrationals

  • Between any two distinct real numbers and , there lie infinitely many irrational numbers.
  • For example, if and , numbers like lie in between.

The Contradiction

  • If takes an irrational value, it violates the condition .
  • Thus, our assumption that is not constant must be false.

Concluding the Constant Function

  • Since cannot be non-constant, it must be a constant function.
  • Therefore, for all .
  • Using the given condition , we get .

Finding

  • We need to find the value of .
  • Since for all :

Key Takeaway

  • A continuous function defined on an interval with a countable range (like or ) must be constant.
  • This is a classic JEE concept testing the interplay of continuity and topology of real numbers.

The Sigma Insight: Continuity at a Point and in an Interval

Analyzing the Setup

Imagine you are standing on a bridge that spans from to . You are holding a pen, and you are tasked with drawing a continuous line that represents the function .
The rules are strict: your pen can only touch rational coordinates. At , you are anchored at the height .
This problem, at first glance, feels like a riddle, but it is actually a profound test of your understanding of the topology of real numbers. Let us peel back the layers of this mystery together.

The Trap of the Wavy Path

Many students instinctively try to imagine a function that wiggles around, perhaps oscillating wildly between rational values. They think, "Maybe it can just stay very close to but wiggle slightly?"
Let us test that intuition. Suppose our function is not constant. If it is not constant, there must be two points, and , where the function takes two different rational values, and .
Because the function is continuous, the Intermediate Value Theorem (IVT) kicks in. The IVT is the law of the land for continuous functions; it dictates that if a function starts at and ends at , it must pass through every single real number in the interval between and .

The Density of Irrationals

The Dealbreaker
Here is where the physics of the problem collapses the possibility of a non-constant function. Between any two distinct real numbers and , there exists an infinite sea of irrational numbers.
If our function were to move from to , it would be forced to cross this sea. It would have to take on irrational values. But the problem explicitly forbids this!
The constraint acts as a cage. The function cannot escape into the irrational realm. Therefore, the only way to satisfy the condition of continuity while remaining strictly within the rational numbers is to never move at all.
The function cannot wiggle, it cannot curve, and it cannot slope. It must be perfectly flat.

The Final Revelation

Since the function must be constant, and we know that , the function must be:
This holds for all in the interval . There is no room for variation.
When we ask for , we are simply looking at another point on this perfectly horizontal line. Thus, .
This problem teaches us that continuity is a powerful, rigid constraint. It binds the function to the topology of the real line, and when combined with a countable range like the rationals, it leaves only one possible outcome: total, unyielding constancy.
Keep this elegant logic in your toolkit; it is a classic JEE Advanced trap that rewards those who look past the algebra to the geometric soul of the function.

Similar Questions

JEE Main 2026 (23 January Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

Let be continuous at . If , then is equal to:

(A)
4
(B)
0
(C)
2
(D)
1
JEE Main 2021 (25 July Shift 2)
LEVELJEE Main

Consider the function and . Where is a polynomial such that is always a constant and . If is continuous at , then is equal to

JEE Main 2020 - 7 Jan (Evening)
LEVELJEE Main

If the function defined on by is continuous, then is equal to . . . .

JEE Main 2019 (09 April Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

If the function defined on by is continuous, then is equal to

(A)
(B)
1
(C)
(D)
2
JEE Main 2018 (16 April Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Advanced

If the function f defined as , is continuous at , then the ordered pair is equal to :

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2018 (15 April Evening)
LEVELJEE Main

Let . The value of k for which f is continuous at x = 2 is :-

(A)
(B)
e
(C)
(D)
1
JEE Main 2025 (January)
LEVELJEE Main

If the function is continuous at , then is equal to

(A)
20
(B)
5
(C)
8
(D)
10
JEE Main 2022 (26 July Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

If and are continuous on , then is equal to :

(A)
-10
(B)
10
(C)
8
(D)
-8
JEE Main 2020 - 5 Sep (Morning)
LEVELJEE Main

Let , for , where denotes the greatest integer function. Then the number of points of discontinuity of is equal to

JEE Main 2020 (7 January Shift 1)
LEVELJEE Main

If the function defined on by is continuous, the is equal to ________.