Imagine a solid sphere of radius R. It holds a total charge of 2Q, but it's not uniformly distributed. The charge density, ρ(r), increases linearly with distance as kr. Now, we place two negative charges, −Q each, at points A and B. These points are diametrically opposite, each at a distance a from the center.
The problem states that charge A experiences zero net force. How is that possible? Look closely at the forces acting on it. Charge B, being negative, will repel A outwards. At the same time, the positive charge of the sphere enclosed within radius a will attract A towards the center. For equilibrium, these two opposing forces must perfectly balance each other.
Finding the Constant k
First, we need to find the value of the constant k. We know the total charge is 2Q. Let's consider a thin spherical shell of radius r and thickness dr. Its volume is 4πr2dr. The charge in this shell, dQ, is density times volume.
dQ=ρ(r)dV=(kr)(4πr2dr)=4πkr3dr
Integrating this from 0 to R gives us the total charge.
2Q=∫0R4πkr3dr=4πk[4r4]0R
Solving this integral, we find that k equals 2Q divided by πR4.
Electric Field at Distance a
Next, let's find the electric field at distance a from the center. We'll use Gauss's Law. We draw a Gaussian sphere of radius a. The charge enclosed is found by integrating our density function from 0 to a.
Applying Gauss's Law, the electric field E comes out to be k times a2 divided by 4ε0.
E(4πa2)=ε04πk(4a4)=ε0πka4
The Master Equation
Now, let's substitute the value of k into our electric field expression. The field E becomes 2Qa2 divided by 4πε0R4. The attractive force on charge A, let's call it F1, is simply its charge Q multiplied by this electric field. This is the inward pull exerted by the inner positive sphere.
E=4ε01(πR42Q)a2=4πε0R42Qa2
What about the outward push? Charge B is at a distance of 2a from charge A. Using Coulomb's Law, the repulsive force F2 between them is 4πε01 times Q2 divided by the square of the distance, which is (2a)2. This simplifies to Q2 over 4πε0(4a2).
F2=4πε01(2a)2Q⋅Q=4πε0(4a2)Q2
Final Calculation
Finally, for charge A to be in equilibrium, we equate the attractive force F1 and the repulsive force F2.
4πε0R42Q2a2=4πε0(4a2)Q2
Notice how beautifully Q2 and 4πε0 cancel out from both sides! Cross-multiplying gives us 8a4=R4.
Taking the fourth root, we get our final answer: a=8−1/4R. This problem is a brilliant fusion of Gauss's Law and Coulomb's Law. Think about this: what if the charge density was uniform instead of varying with r? The electric field would be proportional to r, not r2, leading to a completely different equilibrium position. Always be prepared for such conceptual twists in JEE Advanced!