Analyzing the Anatomy of the Expression
Welcome, aspiring engineer. Today, we are going to dismantle a problem that, at first glance, looks like a tangled web of inverse trigonometric functions. It is designed to intimidate, but beneath the surface, it is a masterpiece of symmetry.
We are given the expression:
E=cot−1{β+α−β1+β2}+cot−1{γ+β−γ1+γ2}+cot−1{α+γ−α1+α2}
This is subject to the strict constraint α>β>γ>0. This constraint is our North Star; without it, we would be lost in a sea of undefined values.
The First Two Terms
A Pattern Emerges
Let us isolate the first term, T1=cot−1(β+α−β1+β2). To simplify this, we take the common denominator inside the bracket:
T1=cot−1(α−ββ(α−β)+1+β2)=cot−1(α−βαβ−β2+1+β2)
The −β2 and +β2 terms vanish, leaving us with cot−1(α−β1+αβ). Since α>β>0, the argument is positive, allowing us to use the identity cot−1x=tan−1(1/x).
This transforms T1 into:
T1=tan−1(1+αβα−β)=tan−1α−tan−1β
The second term, T2, follows the exact same logic. By symmetry, we find:
The Trap
The Third Term
Now, we arrive at the third term, T3=cot−1(α+γ−α1+α2). Applying the same algebraic steps:
T3=cot−1(γ−αα(γ−α)+1+α2)=cot−1(γ−α1+αγ)
Here is where the JEE examiner is watching you. Look at the denominator: γ−α. Because α>γ, this denominator is negative, meaning the argument of the cot−1 function is negative.
We must use the property cot−1x=π+tan−1(1/x) for x<0. Therefore:
T3=π+tan−1(1+αγγ−α)=π+tan−1γ−tan−1α
The Grand Cancellation
We now combine our three pieces: T1=tan−1α−tan−1β, T2=tan−1β−tan−1γ, and T3=π+tan−1γ−tan−1α. Summing them up:
E=(tan−1α−tan−1β)+(tan−1β−tan−1γ)+(π+tan−1γ−tan−1α)
Watch the magic: tan−1α cancels with −tan−1α, −tan−1β cancels with tan−1β, and −tan−1γ cancels with tan−1γ. We are left with exactly:
E=π
You have successfully navigated the trap. The lesson here is simple but profound: never blindly apply identities. Always respect the domain and the sign of the argument.