The beauty of physics often lies in the elegant cancellation of terms, revealing a deeper symmetry in the problem. This classic JEE Advanced question from 1996 is a perfect example of how avoiding premature rounding can save you from a subtle trap!
Analyzing the Setup
Imagine a standard Young's Double Slit Experiment (YDSE)
Now, take the entire apparatus and submerge it in a liquid with a refractive index of μl=1.33.
We are given:
Slit separation, d=1 mm=10−3 m
Distance to screen, D=1.33 m
* Wavelength in air, λ=6300 A˚
When light enters a denser medium, its speed decreases, and consequently, its wavelength shrinks. The new wavelength in the liquid is:
λ′=μlλ=1.336300 A˚≈4737 A˚
The Master Equation for Fringe Width
The fringe width ω is the distance between consecutive bright or dark fringes
The formula remains the same, but we must use the new wavelength
λ′:
ω=dλ′D=μldλD
Notice the brilliant design of the problem! The distance
D=1.33 m and the refractive index
μl=1.33 are numerically identical. They cancel out perfectly:
ω=1.33×10−36300×10−10×1.33=6.3×10−4 m=0.63 mm
The Glass Slab and the Rounding Trap
Next, a glass slab of thickness t and refractive index μg=1.53 is placed in front of one of the slits
This introduces an additional optical path.
The path difference created by the slab
in the liquid medium is:
Δx=(μlμg−1)t=(1.331.53−1.33)t=1.330.20t
We want the adjacent minimum to shift to the central axis
O. The central axis originally had zero path difference (a maximum). To become the first minimum, the new path difference must be exactly half a wavelength:
Δx=2λ′=2μlλ
Equating the two expressions:
1.330.20t=2×1.336300 A˚
Final Calculation
The Exact Answer
Look at the equation above. The
1.33 in the denominators cancels out beautifully!
0.20t=26300 A˚=3150 A˚
t=0.203150 A˚=15750 A˚=1.575μm
The Trap: If you had calculated λ′≈4737 A˚ and (1.331.53−1)≈0.15, you would get t=2×0.154737=15790 A˚=1.579μm. This is a classic rounding error! By keeping the exact fractions, we bypassed the error and arrived at the pristine, exact answer of 1.575μm.