Sigma Percentile
JEE Main 2019
LEVELJEE Advanced

Animated Solution for Physics - Physics and Measurement: The diameter and height of a cylinder are measured by a meter scale to be and , respectively. What will be the value of its volume in appropriate significant figures ?

Select Answer:

Visualized Solution

Visualizing the Cylinder

  • Given measurements:
  • Diameter,
  • Height,

Volume Formula

  • The volume of a cylinder is given by:
  • Since , we can write:

Substituting Values

  • Substitute the central values into the formula:

Calculating Volume & Significant Figures

  • Both and have significant figures.
  • Therefore, the volume must be rounded to significant figures:

Error Propagation Formula

  • For , the fractional error is:

Substituting Errors

  • Substitute the absolute errors and central values:

Calculating Fractional Error

Calculating Absolute Error

  • Multiply fractional error by the unrounded volume:
  • Rounding to appropriate precision:

Final Answer

  • Combining the rounded volume and absolute error:

The Sigma Insight: Errors in Measurement

Solution Diagram

Analyzing the Setup

Imagine you are in a laboratory, holding a solid cylinder. You take out a standard meter scale and carefully measure its dimensions. You find the diameter to be and the height to be . Because you are using a meter scale, your measurements are limited by its least count, which is . Therefore, your readings are recorded as and .
Our goal is to calculate the volume of this cylinder and, more importantly, to express it with the correct significant figures and uncertainty. This is a classic problem that tests not just your ability to plug numbers into a formula, but your understanding of how precision propagates through mathematical operations.

The Master Equation for Volume

The volume of a cylinder is given by the well-known geometric formula . Since our measurement is in terms of diameter , we substitute to get:
Let's first calculate the central value of the volume by substituting the measured values without their uncertainties:
When you punch this into a calculator, you get a highly precise-looking number: . But wait! Is our result really that precise?

The Art of Significant Figures

This is where the rules of significant figures come into play. A chain is only as strong as its weakest link, and a calculated result is only as precise as its least precise input.
Look at our measured values: has exactly three significant figures, and also has exactly three significant figures. According to the rules of multiplication, our final result must be restricted to the same number of significant figures as the input with the fewest significant figures.
Therefore, we must round to three significant figures. The first three digits are and . The next digit is , which is less than , so we round down. This gives us our properly rounded central volume:

Propagating the Errors

Now, we need to figure out the uncertainty, or absolute error, in our volume. When physical quantities are multiplied or divided, their fractional (or relative) errors add up. Furthermore, if a quantity is raised to a power, its fractional error is multiplied by that power.
Applying this rule to our volume formula , we get the error propagation equation:
Notice that the constant disappears because exact constants have zero uncertainty. Let's substitute our values into this equation:
Calculating the individual fractions gives:
To find the absolute error , we multiply this total fractional error by the unrounded volume. It is crucial to use the unrounded volume () here to prevent intermediate rounding errors from skewing the final uncertainty.

Final Calculation and Conclusion

In experimental physics, absolute errors represent the bounds of our uncertainty. It doesn't make sense to state an uncertainty with high precision. By convention, we round the absolute error to one significant figure, or to match the decimal place of the least precise measurement.
Rounding gives us an absolute error of . Finally, we combine our rounded central volume with our rounded absolute error to state the final result:
This perfectly matches option (b). The beauty of this problem lies in the seamless integration of geometry, error analysis, and the strict discipline of significant figures.

Similar Questions

JEE Advanced 2024
LEVELJEE Main

The dimensions of a cone are measured using a scale with a least count of . The diameter of the base and the height are both measured to be . The maximum percentage error in the determination of the volume is -

JEE Main 2020
LEVELJEE Main

The density of a solid metal sphere is determined by measuring its mass and its diameter. The maximum error in the density of the sphere is . If the relative errors in measuring the mass and the diameter are and respectively, the value of is ....... .

JEE Main 2011
LEVELJEE Main

The density of a solid ball is to be determined in an experiment. The diameter of the ball is measured with a screw gauge, whose pitch is and there are divisions on the circular scale. The reading on the main scale is and that on the circular scale is divisions. If the measured mass of the ball has a relative error of , the relative percentage error in the density is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2019
LEVELJEE Main

In the density measurement of a cube, the mass and edge length are measured as kg and m, respectively. The error in the measurement of density is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2018
LEVELJEE Main

The density of a material in the shape of a cube is determined by measuring three sides of the cube and its mass. If the relative errors in measuring the mass and length are respectively and , the maximum error in determining the density is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2004
LEVELJEE Main

A wire has a mass , radius and length . The maximum percentage error in the measurement of its density is

(A)
1
(B)
2
(C)
3
(D)
4
JEE Main 2020
LEVELJEE Main

A physical quantity depends on four observables and , as . The percentages of error in the measurement of and are , , and respectively. The percentage of error in is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

A student determined Young's modulus of elasticity using the formula . The value of is taken to be , without any significant error, his observations are as following. Then, the fractional error in the measurement of is

(A)
0.0083
(B)
0.0155
(C)
0.155
(D)
0.083
JEE Main 2021
LEVELJEE Main

In order to determine the Young's modulus of a wire of radius (measured using a scale of least count ) and length (measured using a scale of least count ), a weight of mass (measured using a scale of least count ) was hanged to get the elongation of (measured using a scale of least count ). What will be the fractional error in the value of Young's modulus determined by this experiment?

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
JEE Main 2020
LEVELJEE Main

A simple pendulum is being used to determine the value of gravitational acceleration at a certain place. The length of the pendulum is and a stop watch with resolution measures the time taken for oscillations to be . The accuracy in is

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)