The Magnetic Clue
Imagine you are a detective, and the magnetic moment is your first major clue. We are given a d6 metal ion forming a complex with aqua (H2O) ligands, and its spin-only magnetic moment is 4.90 BM.
The spin-only magnetic moment formula is our trusty magnifying glass:
By substituting μ=4.90, we get n(n+2)≈24. Solving this simple quadratic equation reveals that n=4. This means our metal ion has exactly 4 unpaired electrons.
The Geometry Dilemma
Octahedral vs. Tetrahedral
Now, here is where many students fall into a trap. A d6 ion with 4 unpaired electrons could theoretically form either a high-spin octahedral complex or a high-spin tetrahedral complex. Water is a weak field ligand, meaning the crystal field splitting energy is less than the pairing energy, so the electrons will avoid pairing up if possible.
Let's test the octahedral hypothesis first. In an octahedral field, the d6 high-spin configuration is t2g4eg2. The Crystal Field Stabilization Energy (CFSE) would be:
CFSEoct=(−0.4×4+0.6×2)Δ0=−0.4Δ0
If we look at our options, −0.4Δ0 is nowhere to be found! This brilliant question uses the options to guide our logic. Therefore, the complex must be tetrahedral, where the metal ion undergoes sp3 hybridization with four water ligands.
The Crystal Field Splitting
Let's visualize the splitting in a tetrahedral field. The five degenerate d-orbitals split into a lower energy e set (two orbitals) and a higher energy t2 set (three orbitals).
Following Hund's rule for our high-spin d6 ion, we first place one electron in each of the five orbitals. The sixth electron must then pair up in the lowest available energy level, which is the e set.
This gives us the electronic configuration: e3t23.
The Final Calculation
Finally, let's calculate the CFSE for our tetrahedral complex. Each electron in the e set stabilizes the complex by −0.6Δt, and each electron in the t2 set destabilizes it by +0.4Δt.
CFSE=[−0.6×ne+0.4×nt2]Δt
Substituting our electron counts (ne=3 and nt2=3):
CFSE=[−1.8+1.2]Δt=−0.6Δt
Thus, the geometry is tetrahedral and the CFSE is −0.6Δt, leading us confidently to the correct option.