The Spinning Vessel
A Thought Experiment
Imagine you are holding a cup of coffee and you start spinning it around its vertical axis. What happens? The coffee climbs up the walls of the cup, leaving a depression in the center. This isn't just a random splash; nature follows strict mathematical rules, and the surface forms a perfect geometric shape known as a paraboloid.
In this classic JEE problem, we are asked to find the exact height difference h between the liquid at the center and the liquid at the edge of a cylindrical vessel of radius R=5 cm, spinning with an angular velocity ω. To solve this elegantly, we need to shift our perspective.
Stepping into the Rotating Frame
Analyzing the fluid from the ground frame can be tricky because every particle is accelerating towards the center (centripetal acceleration). Instead, let's step into the rotating frame of the vessel.
In this rotating frame, the fluid appears completely at rest. This means every tiny fluid particle on the surface is in dynamic equilibrium. Let's pick a random fluid particle of mass m at coordinates (x,y) on the surface and draw its Free Body Diagram.
Three forces act on this particle:
1. The downward pull of gravity: mg.
2. The outward centrifugal pseudo force: mxω2.
3. The normal reaction from the surrounding fluid: N, which acts strictly perpendicular to the liquid surface.
The Geometry of the Surface
Because the particle is in equilibrium, the forces must balance perfectly. Let's say the normal force N makes an angle θ with the vertical.
Balancing the vertical forces, the upward component of the normal force must support the weight:
Ncosθ=mg
Balancing the horizontal forces, the inward component of the normal force must counteract the outward pseudo force:
Nsinθ=mxω2
Now, let's divide the horizontal equation by the vertical equation. The normal force
N and the mass
m beautifully cancel out, leaving us with:
tanθ=gω2x
Here is where the physics meets the calculus. Geometrically, the normal is perpendicular to the tangent of the surface. This means the angle θ the normal makes with the vertical is exactly equal to the angle the tangent makes with the horizontal. And we know that the tangent of this angle is simply the slope of the curve, dxdy!
The Final Calculation
We have a simple differential equation. Let's separate the variables and integrate to find the shape of the surface:
∫dy=∫gω2xdx
Integrating both sides, we get the equation of our paraboloid:
y=2gω2x2
To find the maximum height difference
h, we look at the edge of the vessel where
x=R=5 cm. At this point, the height
y is exactly
h. Substituting these values into our master equation:
h=2gω2(5)2=2g25ω2
And there we have it! The height difference is perfectly predicted by the interplay of rotation and gravity.