Animated Solution for Physics - Electrostatics: A cube of side a has point charges +Q located at each of its vertices except at the origin, where the charge is −Q. The electric field at the centre of cube is
Select Answer:
Visualized Solution
Analyzing the Setup
Cube of side a
Charges +Q at 7 vertices
Charge −Q at origin (0,0,0)
Principle of Superposition
We can split the charge at the origin:
−Q=+Q+(−2Q)
Symmetry Consideration
Now, we have +Q at all 8 corners.
And an additional −2Q at the origin.
Electric Field due to Symmetrical Charges
Due to symmetry, the electric field at the center from the 8 +Q charges is zero.
E8 charges=0
Net Electric Field
The net electric field is solely due to the −2Q charge at the origin.
Enet=E−2Q
Vector Form of Electric Field
E=4πε01r3qr
where r is the position vector of the center.
Position Vector of Center
Center coordinates: (2a,2a,2a)
r=2a(x^+y^+z^)
Magnitude of Position Vector
r=∣r∣=(2a)2+(2a)2+(2a)2
r=23a
Substituting Values
E=4πε01(23a)3−2Q[2a(x^+y^+z^)]
Final Expression
E=4πε01833a3−2Q2a(x^+y^+z^)
E=33πε0a2−2Q(x^+y^+z^)
Conclusion
The electric field points towards the origin.
Symmetry simplifies complex vector additions.
00:00 / 00:00
The Sigma Insight: Electric Field
Solution Diagram
The Beauty of Symmetry in Physics
Imagine standing in a room where every single corner is pulling you with an equal force. What happens? You don't move. You are in perfect equilibrium. This is the profound power of symmetry in physics, and it is exactly the secret weapon we will use to dismantle this seemingly complex JEE problem.
At first glance, calculating the electric field at the center of a cube with charges scattered across its vertices looks like a mathematical nightmare. We have a cube of side a. Seven of its corners host a positive charge +Q, while the origin stubbornly holds a negative charge −Q. If we were to calculate the electric field vector for each of these eight charges individually and sum them up, we would be drowning in a sea of components, angles, and square roots.
But as elite problem solvers, we don't work harder; we work smarter.
The Masterstroke
Superposition
The principle of superposition tells us that the net electric field is simply the vector sum of individual fields. But it also allows us to play a clever mathematical trick. What if we could artificially create perfect symmetry?
Let's focus on that odd −Q charge at the origin. Mathematically, we can rewrite −Q as the sum of +Q and −2Q.
−Q=+Q+(−2Q)
Why on earth would we do this? Because by placing a +Q and a −2Q at the origin, we haven't changed the physical reality of the problem (the net charge there is still −Q), but we have completely transformed the geometry!
Now, look at the cube. We have a +Q charge at every single one of the eight corners.
The Power of Cancellation
Because the cube is perfectly symmetrical, the electric field produced by a +Q charge at any corner is exactly canceled by the electric field produced by the +Q charge at the diametrically opposite corner.
At the exact center of the cube, the vector sum of the electric fields from all eight +Q charges is a beautiful, resounding zero.
E8 charges=0
Suddenly, our nightmare problem has vanished. The only charge that actually contributes to the net electric field at the center is the "leftover" −2Q charge sitting at the origin.
The Mathematical Execution
Now, we just need to find the electric field produced by a single point charge −2Q at the center of the cube. We will use the vector form of Coulomb's law:
E=4πε01r3qr
First, we need the position vector r of the center of the cube relative to the origin. Since the center lies exactly halfway along each edge, its coordinates are (a/2,a/2,a/2).
r=2a(x^+y^+z^)
Next, we calculate the magnitude of this position vector, which is the distance from the origin to the center. Using the 3D distance formula:
r=(2a)2+(2a)2+(2a)2=23a
The Final Calculation
With our components ready, we substitute q=−2Q, r, and r into our electric field equation:
E=4πε01(23a)3−2Q[2a(x^+y^+z^)]
Let's carefully expand the denominator:
(23a)3=833a3
Substituting this back in:
E=4πε01833a3−2Q2a(x^+y^+z^)
E=4πε0133a3−16Q2a(x^+y^+z^)
E=4πε0133a2−8Q(x^+y^+z^)
Finally, simplifying the constants by canceling the 4 in the denominator with the 8 in the numerator, we arrive at our elegant final answer:
E=33πε0a2−2Q(x^+y^+z^)
The negative sign perfectly aligns with our physical intuition: since the effective charge at the origin is negative (−2Q), the electric field at the center must point towards the origin, which is exactly the opposite direction of the position vector (x^+y^+z^).
By leveraging symmetry, we bypassed pages of tedious vector addition and arrived at the solution with clarity and precision. This is the hallmark of true mastery in physics!