The Magnetic Hunt Begins
Welcome to a thrilling exploration of magnetic properties in chemistry! In this JEE Advanced 2018 problem, we are tasked with identifying the diamagnetic species from a diverse list of nine chemical entities. The fundamental rule of magnetism in chemistry is beautifully simple: if a species possesses even a single unpaired electron, it is paramagnetic. It will be weakly attracted to an external magnetic field. Conversely, if every single electron is perfectly paired up with a partner of opposite spin, the species is diamagnetic and will be weakly repelled by a magnetic field. Our mission is to hunt down the species with zero unpaired electrons.
Simple Atoms and Odd Electrons
Let's begin with the simplest entities on our list. The hydrogen atom (extH) has an atomic number of 1. Its electronic configuration is simply 1s1. That single electron has no partner, making the hydrogen atom inherently paramagnetic.
Next, we examine the nitrogen dioxide (extNO2) monomer. To determine its magnetic nature, we can simply count its valence electrons. Nitrogen brings 5 valence electrons, and each of the two oxygen atoms brings 6. This gives us a total of 5+2(6)=17 valence electrons. Here is a golden rule: any molecule with an odd number of total electrons must have at least one unpaired electron. It is mathematically impossible to pair up an odd number of items! Therefore, extNO2 is paramagnetic.
The Power of Molecular Orbital Theory
Moving forward, we encounter diatomic species: the superoxide ion (extO2−) and dimeric sulphur in the vapour phase (extS2). Simple Lewis structures fail us here; we must invoke Molecular Orbital Theory (MOT).
The superoxide ion, extO2−, has 17 electrons (16 from the two oxygen atoms plus 1 extra for the negative charge). When we fill the molecular orbitals according to the Aufbau principle, the highest occupied energy level consists of two degenerate π∗ antibonding orbitals. Placing the last three electrons into these orbitals results in one pair and one unpaired electron. Thus, extO2− is paramagnetic.
What about extS2? Sulphur is located directly below oxygen in the periodic table. In the vapour phase, diatomic sulphur behaves analogously to extO2. It has 16 valence electrons, and the last two electrons enter the degenerate π∗ orbitals. Following Hund's rule of maximum multiplicity, they occupy separate orbitals with parallel spins. These two unpaired electrons make extS2 paramagnetic.
The Deceptive Mixed Oxide
Now we face extMn3extO4. This compound is a classic trap! It is not a simple oxide but rather a mixed oxide, structurally formulated as extMnO⋅extMn2extO3. This means manganese exists simultaneously in two different oxidation states within the crystal lattice: +2 and +3.
Let's look at their electronic configurations. extMn2+ has a 3d5 configuration, meaning it has 5 unpaired electrons. extMn3+ has a 3d4 configuration, possessing 4 unpaired electrons. Since both constituent ions are loaded with unpaired d-electrons, extMn3extO4 is highly paramagnetic.
Coordination Chemistry
The Weak Field Dilemma
Our journey takes us into the realm of coordination compounds with (extNH4)2[extFeCl4] and (extNH4)2[extNiCl4].
In the complex ion [extFeCl4]2−, iron is in the +2 oxidation state. A neutral iron atom is [extAr]4s23d6, so extFe2+ is [extAr]3d6. The chloride ion (extCl−) is a weak field ligand. According to Crystal Field Theory, it produces a small crystal field splitting energy (Δt). Because Δt is less than the pairing energy, the electrons prefer to occupy higher energy orbitals rather than pair up. Distributing 6 electrons across the split d-orbitals leaves us with 4 unpaired electrons. It is paramagnetic.
Similarly, in [extNiCl4]2−, nickel is in the +2 oxidation state, giving it a 3d8 configuration. Again, the weak field chloride ligands do not force pairing. Filling 8 electrons into the tetrahedral d-orbital splitting pattern leaves exactly 2 unpaired electrons. This complex is also paramagnetic.
The Final Oxoanions
A Tale of Empty Orbitals
We are down to our last two candidates: potassium manganate (extK2extMnO4) and potassium chromate (extK2extCrO4).
In the manganate ion (extMnO42−), let's determine the oxidation state of manganese. Four oxygen atoms contribute a charge of −8. To result in an overall −2 charge, manganese must be in the +6 oxidation state. A neutral manganese atom is 4s23d5. Removing 6 electrons leaves a single electron in the d-orbitals (3d1). This one unpaired electron makes the manganate ion paramagnetic.
Finally, we analyze the chromate ion (extCrO42−). Using the same logic, chromium is in the +6 oxidation state. A neutral chromium atom has an anomalous configuration of 4s13d5. If we strip away all 6 of these valence electrons to form extCr6+, we are left with a pristine 3d0 configuration!
There are absolutely zero d-electrons left. Every single electron in the core shells is perfectly paired. Therefore, the chromate ion is perfectly diamagnetic.
Out of the nine species provided, only extK2extCrO4 lacks unpaired electrons. The total number of diamagnetic species is exactly 1.